Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

"Removing from ens" message from wrong ensemble #60

Open
andimik opened this issue Feb 28, 2023 · 17 comments
Open

"Removing from ens" message from wrong ensemble #60

andimik opened this issue Feb 28, 2023 · 17 comments

Comments

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor

andimik commented Feb 28, 2023

I wonder why I got the following message on the console:

	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Sraka SID = 0xE4943D, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: MMR SID = 0xE49456, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Maxi SID = 0xE49428, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Maribor SID = 0xE49426, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Krka SID = 0xE49423, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Celje SID = 0xE49413, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Ptuj SID = 0xE49434, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Antena Celje SID = 0xE4965E, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Murski Val SID = 0xE4942A, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Koroski Radio SID = 0xE49452, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Stajerski Val SID = 0xE4943F, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Aktual Kum SID = 0xE49443, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E0A101: Radio Velenje SID = 0xE49448, SCIdS = 0

as these services are all on Slovenian

Ensemble:
0x9300 SLO DAB+ R2 E [ SLO R2 E ] ECC = 0xE4, UTC 60 min, INT = 1, alarm announcements = 0

and not on Austrian Bundesmux

Ensemble:
0xA101 DAB+ Austria [ DAB+ A ] ECC = 0xE0, UTC 60 min, INT = 1, alarm announcements = 0
@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Feb 28, 2023 •
edited
Loading

I could reproduce it. It has to do with toggling between the muxes (Radio Antena and Bob)

Now the message says:

	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Sraka SID = 0xE4943D, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: MMR SID = 0xE49456, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Maxi SID = 0xE49428, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Maribor SID = 0xE49426, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Krka SID = 0xE49423, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Celje SID = 0xE49413, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Ptuj SID = 0xE49434, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Antena Celje SID = 0xE4965E, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Murski Val SID = 0xE4942A, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Koroski Radio SID = 0xE49452, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Stajerski Val SID = 0xE4943F, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Aktual Kum SID = 0xE49443, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49400: Radio Velenje SID = 0xE49448, SCIdS = 0

which is not existing there, but on E49300.

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Mar 2, 2023

What device do you use?

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Mar 2, 2023

RTL Stick.

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Mar 2, 2023

Connected directly or over TCP-IP?

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Mar 2, 2023

Direct

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Mar 2, 2023 •
edited
Loading

Hmm, interesting, I cannot reproduce this behavior. Could you please share more details?

I have understood that you switch 2 services each from different ensemble and during switching you see these messages. Is any of that 2 services in both ensembles? Is service list broken after switch?

Maybe sharing video would help again.

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Mar 2, 2023

A video won't help you. I just saw this message in the console. The list of services was looking good.

I know that it has to do with weak signals, but I wonder why AbracaDABra mixed up the ensembles...

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Mar 3, 2023

Yes, mixing of the IQ data was my idea too, that is why I have asked about device. It should not happen when RTLSDR is used directly because I always stop the stream and then I start it again to avoid mixing of data. This is unfortunately making tune slower but I have not found better way to avoid mixing of the stream. On the other hand it should be safe unless the underlying layer is leaving old data in buffers and sending them on new start. I will try to reproduce the issue on Linux, on Mac it does not happen. I was trying to switch 2 services from 2 different ensembles many times and it did not happen. I assume you compiled the latest version from repository on Linux, you are not using AppImage, correct?

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Mar 3, 2023

I am always referring to the latest commit, which I am compiling myself.

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Mar 3, 2023

This is what I have in terminal output under Ubuntu 22.04 when switching between Classic Praha and Expres FM. Both are in both ensembles, I ma switching between Classic @ 7C and Express @ 7A. There is obviously no problem.

Allocating 15 zero-copy buffers
	Service: DAB Test HQ SID = 0xE22F75, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Classic Praha SID = 0xE2244A, SCIdS = 0
	Service: DAB Test LQ SID = 0xE22F77, SCIdS = 0
	Service: 'Rádio SÁZAVA SID = 0xE22FBA, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Schwarzwaldradio SID = 0xE0100D, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Schlager Radio SID = 0xE01735, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Kiss SID = 0xE22FA0, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Country Radio SID = 0xE22F37, SCIdS = 0
	Service: COLOR MusicRadio SID = 0xE22442, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Spin Radio SID = 0xE22F43, SCIdS = 0
	Service: HEY Radio SID = 0xE224F8, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Expres FM SID = 0xE2203B, SCIdS = 0
AAC-LC 48 kHz stereo
Output SR = 48000, channels = 2
Allocating 15 zero-copy buffers
	Service: RADIO BONTON SID = 0xE22430, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio BEAT SID = 0xE22F31, SCIdS = 0
	Service: BLANIK DAB SID = 0xE22F3C, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Expres FM SID = 0xE2203B, SCIdS = 0
	Service: HITRADIO CITY SID = 0xE22F32, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Classic Praha SID = 0xE2244A, SCIdS = 0
	Service: RadioZET SID = 0xE2210E, SCIdS = 0
	Service: PIGY RADIO SID = 0xE22FB7, SCIdS = 0
	Service: EVROPA 2 SID = 0xE22204, SCIdS = 0
	Service: FREKVENCE 1 SID = 0xE22205, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Cesky Impuls SID = 0xE22FB4, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Dechovka SID = 0xE224B2, SCIdS = 0
	Service: ROCKZONE SID = 0xE22445, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Impuls SID = 0xE22203, SCIdS = 0
HE-AAC v2 48 kHz stereo
Output SR = 48000, channels = 2
Allocating 15 zero-copy buffers
	Service: 'Rádio SÁZAVA SID = 0xE22FBA, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Schwarzwaldradio SID = 0xE0100D, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Schlager Radio SID = 0xE01735, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Kiss SID = 0xE22FA0, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Country Radio SID = 0xE22F37, SCIdS = 0
	Service: COLOR MusicRadio SID = 0xE22442, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Spin Radio SID = 0xE22F43, SCIdS = 0
	Service: HEY Radio SID = 0xE224F8, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Expres FM SID = 0xE2203B, SCIdS = 0
	Service: DAB Test HQ SID = 0xE22F75, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Classic Praha SID = 0xE2244A, SCIdS = 0
	Service: DAB Test LQ SID = 0xE22F77, SCIdS = 0
AAC-LC 48 kHz stereo
Output SR = 48000, channels = 2

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Mar 9, 2023

Do you use RTL-SDR from Ubuntu installation or do you compile it by yourself from this repository https://github.com/old-dab/rtlsdr ?

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Mar 10, 2023 •
edited
Loading

I am using the version from Ubuntu.

But I also fear this is a timing issue. Maybe you should check the function which is writing this wrong text to the console.

AbracaDABra/gui/servicelist.cpp

Line 315 in c3dc1e6

if ((*it)->isObsolete())

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Mar 10, 2023

I can remove the message but this does not solve the issue. I let it there by purpose to be able to detect these situations.
I was asking about the rtl-sdr version because I was playing with old-dab's rtlsdr yesterday and saw this issue under MacOS so I was curious if we both use the same libraries under Ubuntu.

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Apr 24, 2023

Just had the same message with Airspy, so this is not related to the dongle.

RadioControlEvent::SERVICE_STOP error 2
	Service: PRVI SID = 0xE49201, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio 1 DAB SID = 0xE49442, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Ekspres Slo SID = 0xE49462, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio 1 80-a SID = 0xE49459, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Salomon SID = 0xE49463, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Rock Radio Slo SID = 0xE49516, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Center Slo SID = 0xE49414, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Ognjisce SID = 0xE4932F, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Si SID = 0xE4933A, SCIdS = 0
	Service: VAL 202 SID = 0xE49202, SCIdS = 0
	Service: ARS SID = 0xE49203, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Veseljak SID = 0xE49449, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Aktual SID = 0xE4941C, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio City SID = 0xE49415, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Student SID = 0xE49440, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Net FM SID = 0xE4942B, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: 'WELLE 1 SID = 0xE0AD58, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: *STEPHANSDOM* SID = 0xE0AC52, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Antenne Österrei SID = 0xE0AD57, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: KLASSIK RADIO SID = 0xE0AD53, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Rock Antenne SID = 0xE0AD27, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: arabella HOT SID = 0xE0AD59, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Radio Maria SID = 0xE0A3DD, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: jö.live SID = 0xE0AD56, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: ERF Süd SID = 0xE0AD24, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: -AUSTRIA SID = 0xE0A3E0, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: arabella RELAX SID = 0xE0AD54, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: #Technikum ONE SID = 0xE0AD2A, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Mein Kinderradio SID = 0xE0AD55, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: ENERGY SID = 0xE0AC51, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: * 88.6 * SID = 0xE0AC47, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Radio Flamingo SID = 0xE0AD5A, SCIdS = 0
	Service: PRVI SID = 0xE49201, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio 1 DAB SID = 0xE49442, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Ekspres Slo SID = 0xE49462, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio 1 80-a SID = 0xE49459, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Salomon SID = 0xE49463, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Rock Radio Slo SID = 0xE49516, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Center Slo SID = 0xE49414, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Ognjisce SID = 0xE4932F, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Si SID = 0xE4933A, SCIdS = 0
	Service: VAL 202 SID = 0xE49202, SCIdS = 0
	Service: ARS SID = 0xE49203, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Veseljak SID = 0xE49449, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Aktual SID = 0xE4941C, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio City SID = 0xE49415, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Student SID = 0xE49440, SCIdS = 0
	Service: Radio Net FM SID = 0xE4942B, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: 'WELLE 1 SID = 0xE0AD58, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: *STEPHANSDOM* SID = 0xE0AC52, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Antenne Österrei SID = 0xE0AD57, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: KLASSIK RADIO SID = 0xE0AD53, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Rock Antenne SID = 0xE0AD27, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: arabella HOT SID = 0xE0AD59, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Radio Maria SID = 0xE0A3DD, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: jö.live SID = 0xE0AD56, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: ERF Süd SID = 0xE0AD24, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: -AUSTRIA SID = 0xE0A3E0, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: arabella RELAX SID = 0xE0AD54, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: #Technikum ONE SID = 0xE0AD2A, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Mein Kinderradio SID = 0xE0AD55, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: ENERGY SID = 0xE0AC51, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: * 88.6 * SID = 0xE0AC47, SCIdS = 0
	Removing from ens E49200: Radio Flamingo SID = 0xE0AD5A, SCIdS = 0

9200 is Slovenian DAB, not Austria ...

Could you add a debug message when tuning to a block (like tuning to block xxx) and service (playing Radio xxx).

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Apr 24, 2023 •
edited
Loading

This is an interesting screenshot. Found 2 ensembles (6A and 8A, both DAB+ Austria), but only shows one line this time.

Seems this may cause the above mentioned issue as both blocks have 32 services in total, not 16.

grafik

Normally, both blocks are listed here.

grafik

@KejPi
Copy link
Owner

KejPi commented Apr 26, 2023

I have added the messages in e6598e5
Do you have any test case to reproduce the issue or it is more like random?

@andimik
Copy link
Contributor Author

andimik commented Apr 26, 2023

I fear it's more like random.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@KejPi @andimik