diff --git a/.DS_Store b/.DS_Store index eb9631d..cf94f77 100644 Binary files a/.DS_Store and b/.DS_Store differ diff --git a/_Documents/.DS_Store b/_Documents/.DS_Store new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5008ddf Binary files /dev/null and b/_Documents/.DS_Store differ diff --git a/minutes/.DS_Store b/minutes/.DS_Store index d61ae7b..5a659b4 100644 Binary files a/minutes/.DS_Store and b/minutes/.DS_Store differ diff --git a/minutes/2024-06-07/ADRG.png b/minutes/2024-06-07/ADRG.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4aa4673 Binary files /dev/null and b/minutes/2024-06-07/ADRG.png differ diff --git a/minutes/2024-06-07/dates.png b/minutes/2024-06-07/dates.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c8607d5 Binary files /dev/null and b/minutes/2024-06-07/dates.png differ diff --git a/minutes/2024-06-07/index.qmd b/minutes/2024-06-07/index.qmd new file mode 100644 index 0000000..340035e --- /dev/null +++ b/minutes/2024-06-07/index.qmd @@ -0,0 +1,109 @@ +--- +title: "Minutes 2024-06-07" +date: 2024-06-07 +--- + +::: {.callout-tip collapse="true"} +## View Attendee List + +- Ben Straub (GSK) +- Eva Li +- Heidi Curinckx (Johnson & Johnson) +- HyeSoo Cho (FDA) +- Ismael Alejandro Rodriguez (Appsilon) +- Jane Owens (Phuse & Eli Lilly) +- Joel Laxamana (Roche/Genentech) +- Joseph Rickert (R Consortium) +- Lovemore Gakava (Novo Nordisk) +- Ning Leng (Roche/Genentech) +- Paul Schuette (FDA) +- Saghir Bashir (Argenx) +- Stephanie Lussier (Moderna) +- Steven Hasendinckx (Johnson & Johnson) +- YounKyeong Chang (FDA) +::: + +The meeting was recorded and the [video](https://zoom.us/rec/share/cMcaFb0OOQmcFhdwktFrFu31Bd3ANXFm91ugZqe5WzRM0erMMzQVhYDBd1fa_Am8.ATQgpOrlYiLru6b4?startTime=1717776258000) is available. + +## PharmaSUG Conference + +* Both Ben Straub (Pilot 3) and Ismael Rodriguez (Pilot 4) gave talks at the recent [Pharma SUG](https://www.pharmasug.org/us/index.html) conference which was held in Baltimore. +* Both reported that there was a lot of interest in their talks +* Ben reported that he spoke to several people who thought the the FDA only approves SAS submissions. +* Both presentations will be placed in the R Submissions WG GitHub repository. + +## Coordination with R Package Validation + +* Ismael noted that Magnus from a package validation working group approached him about cooperating with the Submissions WG. +* JBR asked Ismael to ask Magnus to write to him and said that we be happy to invite Magnus to our meetings. + + +## Pilot 3 + +Hye Soo Cho and YounKyeong Chang provided an update on their review of the Pilot 3 submission. + +* The FDA eviewers are wrapping up their review. +* There are no major issues. +* They were able to install the Util package from the zip file and review the R programs to drive the ADaM data sets. +* QC of the ADRG did turn up a minor issue regarding inconsistencies among three date variables. + * The discussion of this issue begins at **7:55** in the video and is illustrated in the screen capture below. + * The recommended solution is that the date origin should be specified in ISO 8601 date/time format in the ADRG. + * Joel agreed to review the record of issues with Pilot 3 and see if there are any other parameters that ought to be explicitly mentioned in the ADRG. + +![](dates.png) + + +## Pilot 4 + +Eric Nantz described progress on the Pilot 4 Submission. + +* The end of June is still our target for the WebAssembly version of Pilot 4. +* The plan is to do the container version at a later time after the WebAssembly version has been reviewed. +* The question was asked if there are any special rules about package downloads. + * Paul Schuette stated that downloading from CRAN is preferable, that in addition to the serialization FDA Security has mentioned downloads as a potential security problem, but that as far as he knows there are no regulations. + * Eric pointed out that the Docker version of Pilot 4 also requires an image download. + * Eric and Paul will meet to discuss this issue. + * Eric will provide ADRG instructions and he and Paul will investigate, +* Paul noted that the FDA has recently approved WSL (Windows System Linux) + +## ADRG + +There has been discussion within the working group as to whether we should investigate best practices for writing ADRGs for R based submissions. JBR noted that recent comments in issue #112 suggested that we should coordinated with the PHUSE ADRG working group. Discussion begins at **29:00** into the video. + +* As it turned out Jane Owens (Eli Lilly) who is co-lead of the PHUSE ADRG working group was on the call. +* PHUSE owns the ADRG templates +* They are actively working on updating the templates with respect to R in section 7.1 of the template. +* Pilot 3 has documentation on R packages in Section 7 and in an appendix to the ADRG (Section 9). + +![](ADRG.png) + +* PHUSE got its starting point for updating the ADRG for R from J&J which Heidi Curinckx confirmed is based on J&J's participation in the Submissions WG. +* The PHUSE WG will publish their updated template and then send it out for review +* The Submissions WG and the PHUSE ADRG WG will cooperate and share information. +* JBR invited Jane and other members of her WG to attend future meetings. + +## R Versions Blog Post + +A small group led my Ning Leng is working on a blog post aimed at generating consensus about what versions of R might be appropriate for R based submissions at any point in time. + +* The post has been revised to reelect the Submissions WG point of view and ends with a request for readers to comment in an issue that that we will open up on our GitHub repository. +* The post includes paragraphs on how four companies Roche, Lilly, GSK, Pfizer deal internally with versioning and package management issues +* Unfortunately, we must remove the quote from Paul because including it would require FDA approval. +* Will also remove the FDA logo. + +**ACTION:** + +* Ning and the other authors will finalize the text. +* JBR will send a MS word version of the post to Paul for final review. + +## Next meeting + +* Because the July meeting is scheduled on the US July 4th holiday weekend and because of travel to the useR! conference the July meeting will be cancelled. * The next meeting of the submissions WG will be at 9AM Pacific Time on Friday August 2, 2022. + + + + + + + +