[4.2.0]&[4.2.1] Support Brim generation depends on Buildplate Adhesion settings

[GMaidana88]

Application Version
4.2.0 & 4.2.1

Platform
Win 7 x64

Printer
Creality Ender 3

Steps to Reproduce
Enable Support Brim with Buildplate Adhesion set to None or Raft.

Actual Results
Support Brim is not generated if Buildplate Adhesion is set to None or Raft. If the latter is set to Skirt or Brim it's generated correctly.

Expected results
Expected Support Brim generation in all cases, regardless of Buildplate Adhesion selection.

Additional Information
01: Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: None

02: Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: Raft

03: Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: Skirt

04: Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: Brim

[rburema]

Devs, see CURA-6700.

[GregValiant]

I'm cleaning house.
Is this still a problem with current Cura versions (5.8.0 and up)? Can I close this?

[GMaidana88]

Hi Greg,

I just checked on Cura 5.8.0, Win 10:

1. Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: None = Works as expected
2. Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: Raft = Does not generate brim on first support layer
3. Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: Skirt = Works as expected
4. Support Brim: ON, Buildplate Adhesion: Brim = Works as expected

This is a non-issue to me, as I've never encountered a situation where I needed support brim over a raft, but just to be precise about it, this is the actual behaviour:

Cheers!

[GregValiant]

I think it's a non-issue too. The raft supersedes the support brim and so the support brim would not be required in that scenario.
I'll go ahead and close this.

[GMaidana88]

I think it's a non-issue too. The raft supersedes the support brim and so the support brim would not be required in that scenario. I'll go ahead and close this.

My thoughts exactly, go ahead and close it.

Thanks!