mls-04b.spthy

theory MLS04a
begin

builtins: hashing, signing, asymmetric-encryption

// MAC
functions: mac/2

// PKI Provisioning
rule RegisterPK:
  [ Fr(~ltk) ]
  -->
  [
    !Ltk($A, ~ltk),
    !Pk($A, pk(~ltk)),
    Out(pk(~ltk))
  ]

rule RevealLTK:
  [ !Ltk(A, ltk) ]
  --[ LtkReveal(A) ]->
  [ Out(ltk) ]

// Client logic
rule ClientInit:
  let
    gx = pk(~x)
    pkC = pk(ltkC)
    sig = sign(<gx, C, pkC>, ltkC)
    uik = <gx, C, pkC, sig>
  in
  [
    !Ltk(C, ltkC),
    Fr(~x)
  ]
  --[ ClientPostedInitKey(C, gx) ]->
  [
    ClientWait(C, ~x, ltkC),
    Out(uik)
  ]

rule ClientFinish:
  let
    gx = pk(x)
    pkC = pk(ltkC)

    // welcomeInfo = <gy, k, S, pkS>
    welcomeInfo = adec(welcome, x)
    gy = fst(welcomeInfo)
    k = fst(snd(welcomeInfo))
    S = fst(snd(snd(welcomeInfo)))
    pkS = snd(snd(snd(welcomeInfo)))

    // add = <'add', hWelcome, gx, C, pkC, sig>
    addTag = fst(add)
    hWelcome = fst(snd(add))
    gxIn = fst(snd(snd(add)))
    CIn = fst(snd(snd(snd(add))))
    pkCIn = fst(snd(snd(snd(snd(add)))))

    macData = <add, addSig>
    state = <C, S, pkC, pkS, gx, gy>
    confirmKey = mac(k, state)
    macValVer = mac(confirmKey, macData)
  in
  [
    ClientWait(C, x, ltkC),
    !Pk(S, pkS),
    In(<welcome, add, addMAC, addSig>)
  ]
  --[ Neq(gx, gy),
      Eq(addTag, 'add'),
      Eq(hWelcome, h(welcomeInfo)),
      Eq(gxIn, gx),
      Eq(CIn, C),
      Eq(pkCIn, pkC),
      Eq(verify(addSig, add, pkS), true),
      Eq(macValVer, addMAC),
      ClientDone(C, S, gx, gy, k) ]->
  []

// Server logic
rule ServerInit:
  let
    uik = <gx, C, pkC, sig>

    gy = pk(~y)
    pkS = pk(ltkS)
    welcomeInfo = <gy, ~k, S, pkS>
    welcome = aenc(welcomeInfo, gx)

    add = <'add', h(welcomeInfo), uik>
    sigData = add
    addSig = sign(sigData, ltkS)

    macData = <add, addSig>
    state = <C, S, pkC, pkS, gx, gy>
    confirmKey = mac(~k, state)
    addMAC = mac(confirmKey, macData)
  in
  [
    In(<gx, C, sig>),
    !Pk(C, pkC),
    !Ltk(S, ltkS),
    Fr(~y),
    Fr(~k)
  ]
  --[ Eq(verify(sig, <gx, C, pkC>, pkC), true),
      ServerDone(S, C, gx, gy, ~k) ]->
  [
    Out(<welcome, add, addSig, addMAC>)
  ]

// Restrictions
restriction Equality:
  "All x y #i. Eq(x,y) @i ==> x = y"

restriction Inequality:
  "All x y #i. Neq(x,y) @i ==> not(x = y)"

// Functionality test
lemma HonestServerTrace:
  exists-trace
  "
    Ex C S gx gy k #j.
        ServerDone(S, C, gx, gy, k) @ #j
      & not(Ex A #k. LtkReveal(A) @ #k)
  "

lemma HonestTrace:
  exists-trace
  "
    Ex C S gx gy k #i #j.
        ClientDone(C, S, gx, gy, k) @ #i
      & ServerDone(S, C, gx, gy, k) @ #j
      & not(Ex A #k. LtkReveal(A) @ #k)
  "

// If a client has established a session key,
// ... then the server has the same key,
// ... and it is not known to the attacker
// ... unless one of the long-term keys was compromised
lemma KeySecrecy:
  "
  not(Ex C S gx gy k #i #j #k.
        ClientDone(C, S, gx, gy, k) @ #i
      & ServerDone(S, C, gx, gy, k) @ #j
      & K(k) @ #k
      & not(Ex #rc. LtkReveal(C) @ #rc)
      & not(Ex #rs. LtkReveal(S) @ #rs)
  )
  "

// If a client has established a session key
// ... then it's based on a response from a server
lemma ServerLiveness:
  "
  All C S gx gy k #i.
    ClientDone(C, S, gx, gy, k) @ #i
    ==> ( (Ex #j. (ServerDone(S, C, gx, gy, k) @ #j) & (#j < #i))
        | (Ex #rc. LtkReveal(C) @ #rc)
        | (Ex #rs. LtkReveal(S) @ #rs)
        )
  "

// If a server has established a session key
// ... then it's based on a client's init key
lemma ClientLiveness:
  "
  All C S gx gy k #i.
    ServerDone(S, C, gx, gy, k) @ #i
    ==> ( (Ex #j. (ClientPostedInitKey(C, gx) @ #j) & (#j < #i))
        | (Ex #rc. LtkReveal(C) @ #rc)
        | (Ex #rs. LtkReveal(S) @ #rs)
        )
  "

// ... injective agreement
lemma InjectiveAgreement:
  "
  All C S gx gy k #i.
    ServerDone(S, C, gx, gy, k) @ #i
    ==> ( not(Ex C2 S2 gx2 gy2 #i2.
              ServerDone(S2, C2, gx2, gy2, k) @ #i2
             & not(#i2 = #i)
             )
        | (Ex #rc. LtkReveal(C) @ #rc)
        | (Ex #rs. LtkReveal(S) @ #rs)
        )
  "

end