diff --git a/editor/src/components/canvas/canvas-strategies/strategies/set-padding-strategy.tsx b/editor/src/components/canvas/canvas-strategies/strategies/set-padding-strategy.tsx
index 01f65b4b22c2..bb69d4fc2a7c 100644
--- a/editor/src/components/canvas/canvas-strategies/strategies/set-padding-strategy.tsx
+++ b/editor/src/components/canvas/canvas-strategies/strategies/set-padding-strategy.tsx
@@ -270,10 +270,7 @@ export const setPaddingStrategy: CanvasStrategyFactory = (canvasState, interacti
               })),
             ),
           ],
-          // FIXME: This was added as a default value in https://github.com/concrete-utopia/utopia/pull/6408
-          // This was to maintain the existing behaviour, but it should be replaced with a more specific value
-          // appropriate to this particular case.
-          'rerender-all-elements',
+          selectedElements,
         )
       }
 
@@ -301,10 +298,7 @@ export const setPaddingStrategy: CanvasStrategyFactory = (canvasState, interacti
               })),
             ),
           ],
-          // FIXME: This was added as a default value in https://github.com/concrete-utopia/utopia/pull/6408
-          // This was to maintain the existing behaviour, but it should be replaced with a more specific value
-          // appropriate to this particular case.
-          'rerender-all-elements',
+          selectedElements,
         )
       }
 
@@ -334,10 +328,7 @@ export const setPaddingStrategy: CanvasStrategyFactory = (canvasState, interacti
             })),
           ),
         ],
-        // FIXME: This was added as a default value in https://github.com/concrete-utopia/utopia/pull/6408
-        // This was to maintain the existing behaviour, but it should be replaced with a more specific value
-        // appropriate to this particular case.
-        'rerender-all-elements',
+        selectedElements,
       )
     },
   }