Support HTTP/2, HTTP/3 and QUIC in HTTP server

[kitsonk]

This was discussed over in denoland/std#153 but was locked during the move.

While we still have concerns around the HTTP server, we should also consider supporting HTTP/2, HTTP/3 and QUIC.

[hazae41]

#1558

[ry]

It's quite likely that we will expose native HTTP server.

Getting these protocols correct is very difficult - it's better to collaborate with other Rust users. We will probably using warp. (We will be using warp for Chrome DevTools web socket server, so it makes sense to also expose a native WebSocket object using that. Might as well also use it for HTTP bindings.)

The reason why we have std/http and not a native HTTP server is because we're still working out the kinks in the "op model". In our benchmarks deno_tcp is still slower than node_tcp

I want to fix that first before adding the native HTTP since it will be built on top of the same primitives.

[hcldan]

@ry Is there a ticket for those performance benchmarks or any schedule for when it might make it in?

[Justsnoopy30]

What's the status on http/2 support in Deno?

[kitsonk]

The issue is open. That indicates that it isn't resolved yet.

[Justsnoopy30]

The issue is open. That indicates that it isn't resolved yet.

Well yes, I can see that. What I meant was, how much progress has been made on this?

[kitsonk]

Any progress would be mentioned in this issue.

[Dygear]

Apple Push Notification Service is going to require HTTP/2 starting April 1st 2021. Looking over their documentation, it's acceptable to keep a long standing connection to their servers, but requires a PING FRAME about every hour to be sent. So whomever does end up landing HTTP/2, can they please add to option to sending these frames manually, it would be of great help.

[lucacasonato]

@Dygear This is client to sever communication, right? The API for that is fetch and it already supports HTTP/2.

[ry]

We are working on hyper bindings and hope to have them complete for v1.9

[anonrig]

Hi! I'm a maintainer from mali (GRPC microservice framework) and wanted to stay in the loop. We're currently investigating supporting Deno in Mali. If you're interested in this support, please send us a message from malijs/mali#241

[badsyntax]

@anonrig also refer to #3326 for additional discussions about grpc in Deno

[rektide]

PR #9935 is (i believe) a start on those Hyper bindings @ry mentioned!

worth pointing out that Hyper itself is still working on HTTP/3, via a subproject. most of those efforts are currently going in to an h3 library, is my understanding. h3 seems to use the Quinn http/3 implementation.

happy hacking all! thanks everyone!!! 🚀 bonus shout out: PR #9935 is an anagram of this PR #3995!!! eerie coincidence? manifest destiny? what's your take on this little serendipity?

[ynwd]

We are working on hyper bindings and hope to have them complete for v1.9

@ry @kitsonk @lucacasonato
is it possible to change these bindings dynamically - using the fastest rust framework?

https://www.techempower.com/benchmarks/#section=data-r20&hw=ph&test=fortune&l=yyku7z-sf

[bartlomieju]

No, the bindings use hyper and it can't be changed.

[ry]

HTTP/2 shipped in v1.9.0 (see #9935)

HTTP/3 and QUIC can be discussed in a new issue.

[waldyrious]

HTTP/3 and QUIC can be discussed in a new issue.

There is #1558 which was closed as a duplicate (subset) of this one. Maybe it should be reopened, @kitsonk?

[trivikr]

There is #1558 which was closed as a duplicate (subset) of this one. Maybe it should be reopened

The issue #1558 was reopened.