-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 10
/
NAS-NS-3004.txt
4007 lines (2863 loc) · 154 KB
/
NAS-NS-3004.txt
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
704
705
706
707
708
709
710
711
712
713
714
715
716
717
718
719
720
721
722
723
724
725
726
727
728
729
730
731
732
733
734
735
736
737
738
739
740
741
742
743
744
745
746
747
748
749
750
751
752
753
754
755
756
757
758
759
760
761
762
763
764
765
766
767
768
769
770
771
772
773
774
775
776
777
778
779
780
781
782
783
784
785
786
787
788
789
790
791
792
793
794
795
796
797
798
799
800
801
802
803
804
805
806
807
808
809
810
811
812
813
814
815
816
817
818
819
820
821
822
823
824
825
826
827
828
829
830
831
832
833
834
835
836
837
838
839
840
841
842
843
844
845
846
847
848
849
850
851
852
853
854
855
856
857
858
859
860
861
862
863
864
865
866
867
868
869
870
871
872
873
874
875
876
877
878
879
880
881
882
883
884
885
886
887
888
889
890
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
914
915
916
917
918
919
920
921
922
923
924
925
926
927
928
929
930
931
932
933
934
935
936
937
938
939
940
941
942
943
944
945
946
947
948
949
950
951
952
953
954
955
956
957
958
959
960
961
962
963
964
965
966
967
968
969
970
971
972
973
974
975
976
977
978
979
980
981
982
983
984
985
986
987
988
989
990
991
992
993
994
995
996
997
998
999
1000
National
Academy
of
Sciences
National Research Council
NUCLEAR SCIENCE SERIES
The Radiochemistry
of Thorium
b,
NN
AT
7 Energy =
et LR
. COMMITTEE ON CHEMICAL SCIENCES
James. L. Kinsey, Cochairman, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Alan Schriesheim, Cochairman, Exxon Research and Engineering Company
Andreas Acrivos, Stanford University
AIIen\J_. Bard. University of Texas, Austin
Fred Basolo, Northwesfern University
Steven J. Benkovic, Pennsylvania State Universitf
Bruce J. Berne, Columbia University
R. Stephen Berry, University of Chicago
Alfred E. Brown, Celanese Corporation
Ernest L. Eliel, University of North Carolina
Roald Hoffmann, Cornetl University
Rudolph Pariser, E. . Du Pont de Nemours & Co., Inc.
Norman Sutin, Brookhaven National Laboratory
Barry M. Trost, University of Wisconsin
Edel Wasserman, E. |. du Pont de Nemours & Co., inc.
SUBCOMMITTEE ON NUCLEAR AND RADIOCHEMISTRY
Gregory R. Chaoppin, Chairman, Florida State University
Eugene T. Chulick, Babcock & Wilcox Co.
Christopher Gatrousis, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
Peter E. Haustein, Brookhaven National Laboratory
Darleane C. Hoffman, Los Alamos National Laboratory
Paul J. Karol, Carnegie-Mellon University
Michael J. Welch, Washington University School of Medicine
Raymond G. Wymer, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
William H. Zoller, University of Maryland
LIAISON MEMBERS
Fred Basolo, Northwestern University
Theodore L. Cairns, Greenville, Delaware
Gerhart Friedlander, Brookhaven National Laboratory
{(Membership as of January 1982}
The Radiochemistry of Thorium
By E. K. HYDE
Lawrence Radiation Laboraiory
Universily of California
Berkeley, California
January 1960
Reprinted by the Technical Information Center
U. S. Department of Energy
Subcommittee on Radiochemistry
National Academy of Sciences —National Research Council
Price $9.75. Available from:
National Technical Information Service
U. S. Department of Commerce
Springfield, Virginia 22161
Printaed in the United Gtates of America
USDOE Technical informaton Center, Oak Ridge. Tennessse
1960; latest printing June 1982
FOREWORD
The Subcommlttee on Rediochemistry 1s one of a number of
subcommittees working under the Committee on Nuclear Sclence
within the National Academy of Sciences - National Research
Counclil. Its members represent govermment, Industrial, and
university laboratorles 1n the areass of nuclear chemlstry and
analytical chemistry.
The Subcommlttee has concerned 1tself with those areas of
nuclear scilence which involve the chemlst, such as the collec-
tilon and distribution of radliochemical procedures, the estab-
lismment of specifications for radiochemically pure reagents,
the problems of stockpiling unconteminated materials, the
avaellability of cyclotron time for service irradlations, the
place of radiochemistry in the undergraduate college program,
etec.
This series of momograephse has grown out of the need for
up-to-date compllations of radiochemicel Information and pro-
cedures. The Subcommlttee has endeavored to present a series
which will be of maximm use to the working sclentist and
which contains the lateat available Information. Each mono-
graph collects in one volume the pertinent information required
for rediochemical work with an Indlvidual element or & group of
¢closely related elements.
An expert in the radiochemistry of the particular element
has written the monograph, following a standard format developed
by the Subcommittee. The Atomic Energy Commlssion has sponsored
the printing of the serles.
The Subcommittee 1s confident these publications will be
useful not only to the radiochemist but also to the research
worker 1n other fields such as physics, blochemistry or medlcine
who wishes to use radiochemical techniquee to solve a specific
problem.
W. Wayne Meinke, Chslrman
Subcommittee on Radiochemistry
ill
CONTENTS
I. General Reviews of the Inorganic and Analytical Chemistry of
Thorium '
II. General Reviews of the Radiochemistry of' Thorium
ITI.Table of Isotopes of Thorium
IV. Review of those Features of Thorium. Chemis'try of Chief Interest
to
1.
Radiochemlests
Metalllic thorium
Boluble salts of thorium
Insoluble salts of thorlum and coprecipltation characteristics
of thorium
Complex ions of thorium
Chelate complexes of thorium
Extraction of the TTA-complex of thorium fnto organic solvents
Extraction of thorium into organic solvents
Ion Exchange behavior of thorium
V. Collection of Detalled Radiochemical Procedures for Thorium.
w W
BREE o -
INTRODUCTION
This volume which deals with the radiochemistry of thorium
is one of a series of monographs on radiochemistry of the elements.
There is included a review of the nuclear and chemical features
of particular interest to the radiochemist, a discussion of prob-
lemg of dissolution of a sample and counting techniques, and
finally, a collection of radiochemical procedures for the element
as found in the literature.
The series of monographs will cover all elements for which
radiochemical procedures are pertinent. Plans include revision
of the monograph periodically as new techniques and procedures
warrant. The reader is therefore encouraged to call to the
attention of the author any published or unpublished material
on the radiochemistry of thorium which might be included in a
revised version of the monograph.
vi
The Radiochemistry of Thorium
E. K, HYDE
Lawrence Radlation Laboratory
University of Californie, Berkeley, California
January 1960
Table of Isotopes
I. GENERAL REVIEWS OF THE INORGANIC AND ANALYTICAL CEEMISTRY OF THORTUM
Chapter 3, pp 16-66 in "The Chemistry of the Actinide Elements",
J. J. Katz and G. T. Seaborg, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New
York, 1957.
Chapter 4, pp 66-102, "The Chemistry of Thorium" by L. I. Katzin
in the "The Attinide Elements", National Nuclear Energy Series,
Division IV, Plutonium Project Record Volume 14A, edited by G. T.
Seaborg and J. J. Ketz, McGrew-Hill Book Co., New York, 195&4.
Gmelin's Handbuch der Anorganischen Chemie, System Nr. 44, 8th
Edition (Verlag Chemie, GmbH. Weinheim-Bergstrasse, 1955).
C. J. Rodden &nd J. C. Warf, pp 160-207 in "Analytical Chemlstry
of the Manhattan Project", McGraw HEill Book Co., New York, 1950.
"Thorium, pp 946-954, Vol. 1 of "Scott's Standard Methods of
Chemical Analysis", K. H. Furman, editor, D. Van Noetrand Co.,
Inc., New York, 1939.
"The Analytical Aspects of Thorium Chemistry", T. Mueller, G.K.
Schweltzer and D. D. Starr, Chem. Rev. 42, Feb. 1948.
Collected Papers on Methods of Analysis for Uranium and Thorlum
compiled by F. 8. CGrimaldl, I. May, M. H. Fletcher and J.
Titcomb. Geological Survey Bulletin 1006, 1954, for sale by
Superintendent of Documents U. 8. Govermment Printing Office
Washington 25, D. C. Price ¢ 1. -
II. GENERAL REVIEWSOF THE RADIOCHEMISTRY OF THORIUM
Chapter 15, "Radiochemical Separations of the Actinide Elements",
by E. K. Hyde in "The Actinide Elements", edited by G. T. Seaborg
end J. J. Katz, McGraw Hill Book Co., New York, 195L.
Paper P/728, "Radliochemical Separations Methods for the Actinide
Elements" by E. K. Hyde, pp. 281-303, Vol 7, Proceedings of the
International Conference in Geneve, August 1955 on the Peaceful Uses
of Atamic Energy, United Nations, New York, 1956. Single copies of
this paper may be available for 25 cents from United Natlons Book-
stare, New York City.
IIT. TAHLE OF ISOTOPES OF THORIUM
Isotope Half 1life Type of Method of Preparation
Decay
rn2e3 ~0.1 sec o Demghter 1.3 min UPZ!
Thzah ~1l Bec a Daughter 9.3 min 0228 '
The22 8 mn a ~90% Daughter 58 min y229
EC ~10%
Tn?26 30.9 min a Daughter 20.8 day UZ0°
ThE2l 18.17 dsy a Netural redicactivity; dsughter AcZZ!
(RdAc) -
T'J:L228 1.91 year a Netural radiocactivity; dsughter MZZB
(RATh) (MsTh,, )
229 7340 year o Daughter U233
Th23° 80,000 year a Natural radicactivity; daughter Uz3h
(Ionium)
%’hZ?l 25.64 hour B Natural radiosctivity; dsughter U237
UY
™?32 1,39 x 10¥%ear < Natural thorium 1s 100% Th232
233 22.1 min B- ThZ32 4+ neutrons
:(uh23;' 24.1 day B- Natural radlosctivity; dmughter U230
Uxy
For more complete information on the radiations of the thorium isotopes
and for references to original literature, see "Table of Isotopes”, D. Strom-
inger, J. M. Hollander and G. T. Besborg, Reviews of Modern Physics, 30,
No.2, Part II, April 1958. |
IV. REVIEW OF THOSE FEATURES OF THORTUM CHEMISTRY OF CHIEF
IRTEREST TO RADIOCHEMIOSTS
1l. Metgllic Thorium
Thorium metal is highly electropositive and its preparation is a matter
of no mean difficulty. Methods which are used for this purpose include re-
ductlon of thorlum oxide with calclum, reduction of thorium tetrachloride or
tetrafluoride or tetrachloride by calcium, megnesium or sodium or electrolysis
of fused salts. Thorium metal has a high melting point (1750° C) and is
highly reactive in the molten state. The potential of the thorium-thorium (IV)
couple has been egtimated as + 1.90 volts.l A fresh surface of thorium tar-
nishes rapidly in alr and the finely divided metal 18 pyrophoric. The pres-
ence of oxygen and poselbly of nitrogen and other light element impurities
on the surface of thorium can be a matter of some importance in some experi-
ments in nuclear chemlstry or physics where thin foils of thorium are employed
a8 targets.
The reaction of thorlum metal with agueous mineral acids has some featbures
of grea-t Interest to radiochemists. Dilute.hydrofluoric aclid, nitric mecid,
sulfuric acid end concentrated phosphoric acld or perchloric ecld attack mas-
slve thorium metal slowly. Concentrated nitric acid rendere thorium passive
but the additlon of fluoride ion ceuses the dissolutlon to contimue. In the
dissolution of small thorium targets, 1t is found that concentrated HRO3 con-
talning 0.0l molar (N]Ih)z SiF, (or HF) mekes a good solvent mixture. The sol-
vent should be mdded in batches with heatlng and stirring in between rather
than all at once. Hydrochloric acld attacks thorium vigorously but a mysteri-
ous black or blue-black residue remains on completion of the reaction. As
mick as 25 percent of the original metal may be comverted to the black solid
by either dilute or concentrated hydrochloric acid. Most or all of this resl-
due can be dlesclved by adding fluoride lon 1n small concentration to the
hydrochloric acid. The blaeck réesidue may be ThO or it may be a hydride Thgz
For a further discussion of this material see Katzin , James and Stresumanis-,
and Katz and Bea:borgh. | |
Thorium oxide targets csn also be dissolved by a mixture of hydrochloric
acid plus (Nflh)z BiF¢ or of mitric acid plus (Hflh)zflfli‘G. A good discussion of
the fluoride ion catalyzed dissolution of thorium metal or thorium dioxlde is
given by Schuler, Steahly and Stoughton.'®
2. 8oluble Salts of Thorium
Since thorium exists in solution as a comparatively small highly charged
cation, it undergoes extensive interaction with water and with many anions.
There 1s one great simplification in the agueous chemlstry of thorium in that it
hes only one oxidatlon state and hence oxidaetion-reduction reactions do not
need to be considered.
The water soluble salts of thorium include the nitrate, the sulphate, the
chloride and the perchlorate.
3. Ingoluble Balts of ThoriuméPrécipitation and Coprecipitation Character-
isties of thorium
The common Iinsoluble compounds of thorium are listed in Table 1. An
inspection of the table suggests a number of precipitates which may e sultable
for the removal of tracer amounts of thorium from solutlon. Good descriptlons
of the insoluble compounds of thorium and their use in analysis are glven in the
general references listed 1n Part I.
Thorium hydroxide is a highly insoluble compound forming s gelatinous pre-
cipitate when alkal! or ammonium hydroxide 1s added to an aguéous solutlon of
Th*h. It 15 not amphoteric. Thorlum hydroxide dissolves In aquecus solutlions
contalning ions such as clitrate, carbonate, or sulfosallcylic acid which
complex thorium lon. Tracer amounts of thorium will coprecipitate quantitetive-
ly with a wide variety of lnsoluble hydroxides; lanthammm, ferric snd zircon-
TABLE 1 IRSOLUBLE COMPOUNDS OF THORIUM
Reagent Precipitate Solubllity in Solubility in
Water other Reagente
OH ‘Th(OH), very insolgBle soluble in acids,
S.P. = 10~ ammonium oxalate,
alkall carbonates,
sodium cltrate, etc.
F ThF), - hnéo very insoluble soluble 1in acld
aluminum nitrate
solution
Kr + HF KzThFG very lnscluble
Io3' Th(103)4 very insoluble
(even in strong EN03) soluble with reagents
whlch destroy 103
C,0,= Th(Czoh)EGHEO ingoluble in water soluble in excess
or 1ln dilute acid ammonium or potasslium
oxalate
PO, = Th3(P04)h very insoluble diesalves with
difflculty in
Th(HPOh)zHéo concentrated acid
(PO, ) 5, PO; 22,0
BP0~ ThP_0, - 2H_0 extremely insoluble
276 :
276 Hz 1.65x10=*% moles per
liter 4.ON HC1
H;0, + Th(00)230£3320 very insoluble soluble in strong
0.1X stoh mineral ecild
TARIE 1 (Cont'd.)
Reagent Precipitate Solubility in Solubility in
. Water . other Reagents
503= Th(SO3)2H20 partially dissolved in
excesa sulphite
Cr207= Th(Cro,, ), * 38,0 insoluble 1n'320 . soluble in conc,acid
Th(0H) ,Cr0, *E,0
MoQ, = Th(moh)zlmzo ' insoluble soluble in dilute
mineral acids
Fe(CH) gh ThFe(CN) 6-hELzO very insoluble
ium hydroxide bhave been used. Since hydroxide carrier precipitates are notori-
ously non-specific, they should be counted on only to remove thorium from e
simple mixture of contaminants or as a group separation to be followed by more
specific chemlcal purificatlon steps. In some of the classical studies of the
uranium series’ le(Th23h') wag separated from uranium by precipitating ferric
hydroxide and ammonium uranate together and leaching the uranium from the pre-
cipitate with ammonium carbonate.
Thorium peroxide forms when hydrogen peroxide is added to a dilute miner-
al acid containing thorium. It is highly insocluble. The formula ip often
glven &s Th,on but recent investigations suggest that anions are incorporated
into the solld as integral components. The preclse formula of the precipitate
varies with the condltions of precipitation. The physical form 1s aleo greatly
different depending on the acidifiysa: when preclpitated from a neutral solu-
tlon it 1s gelatinous and contains many copreclipltated anions; when preclipi‘ba'bed
from a slightly baslc solution, it i1s not so gelatlnous and has & lower perox-
ide content; when formed in an acid solution, 1t is opaque and readily filtered.
Insoluble peroxide compounds are rare in the Periodic Syst. 8o that preclplta-
tion of thorium peroxlde can provide clean separatlion of thorlum from most other
elements. Plutonium (IV) forme & peroxide similar to tbat of thorium (IV). Other
(IV) state elements such es cerium (IV) and zirconium (IV) aleo form such in-
soluble peroxides. Urenium (IV) and neptunium (IV) also form insoluble precipi-
tates upon the addition of peroxide, but these seem to be of a somewhat differ-
ent type than those formed by thorium and plutonium. These peroxide precipl-
tates are reedily dissolved by the addition of reagents such as Sn(II), I,
MRop or Ce(IV) which can destroy peroxide. For a more complete discussion of
the peroxide and for references to the original literature, see Katz and Sea-
borgs.
Lanthamm Fluoride as Carrier for Thorium. Thorium will coprecipitate
quantitatively with lanthamm precipitated as the fluoride from strongly acidiec
solutions. This is e very useful method for the aeparation of small smounts of
p
thorium from uranium sclutions. The fluoride may be converted to the hydroxide
by direct metathesie with mlkall hydroxdde pellete or strong alkall solutions,
or it may be dissolved in an alumimum nitrate-nitric acid solution (which
thoroughly complexes the fluoride ion) and then be precipitated as the hydroxide,
The coprecipltation of rare esrth impurities 1is, of course, complete. Zircon-
l1um and barium in trace concentrations are carried but, i1f milligrem quantities
of these elements are added as "hold-back carriers”, no coprecipitation is ob-
served. Hence coprecipitation with lanthamum fluoride serves as an excellent
method of freeing thorium from the zirconlum carrier used lIn a previous step.
An slternate method would be the removal of zirconlum on an anlon exchange
regin from an 8-10 molar solution of hydrochloric acid.
Other lnsoluble fluorlides may serve as carriers for trace amounts of thor-
ium.
Zirconium Todate as Qarrier. Zirconium in a cohcentration of 0.1 to 1.0
'mg/ml may be precipitated as the iodete from a strongly acidic solution to
carry thorium nearly quantitatively. The iodate concentration is not critical.
Elements which form insoluble lodates are also coprecipitated, but many, such
as uranium, are separated. The rare earths and actinium are decontamlnated if
the preclpitation i1s from a strongly scidic solution and the preclpitate is
washed with an lodate contalning selution. Under conditions of low acldity
and low total ionic strength, the carrylng of these elements may be gulte high,
as shown for actinium by McLane and PetérsonT. If cerium is present 1t 1s
necessary to reduce Ce(IV) to Ce(III) with eome sulteble reducing egent such as
hydrogen peroxide, before precipitation.
The zirconium lodate may be dissolved in nitrilc acid containing sulfur
dioxide or some other reducing agent, and the zirconium may be repreclpitated
as the hydroxide after the solution 1s boliled to remove ilodine.
Hegemann and his co-m:rkerea8 applied this method to thelr study of the
isotope T]:x229 in the 4n + 1 series. Their procedure is reproduced in Proced-
ure 16 of Section V below. Ba.lloru9 used 1t as a means of substituting zircon-
lum carrler for rare lea.rth carrier after an 1nitial leanthanum fluoride precipl-
tation. See Procedure 13 in Section V below.
Phoephate Precipitates. Thorium precipitates in a varlety of ill-definped
forms in the présence of phosphorous-containing enions. These compounds are
extremely insoluble in.water and in acid solutlion. The hypophosphate is parti-
cularly insoluble. Even in @i Hecl the solubility is only 2.1 x lf)ll' moles per
liter. Other insoluble phosphates such as zirconium phoephate serve as good
carriers for the removal of trace amounts of thorium from-agueous esolution.
Thorium Oxalate. A widely used method of quantitatlive analysis of thorium
is the precipitation of thorium oxalate followed by ignition to thorium dioxide
and weighing of the dioxlde..°
Some camplexing agents lnterfere with the precipitetion of thorium oxalate
by the formation of soluble thorium complexes. Gordon and Shaver report a& meth-
od for the separation of rare earth ions from thorium by precipitation of- phos-
phate-free rare earth oxalates l1n the presence of the strong chela.ting a.gent,
ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA). _
"Organic Aacids which form water-insoluble compounds with thorium vhich are
of possible analytical or radiochemical importance Include sebacic, a.nthranitic,
phenylarsonic, galllic, tennlc, quinaldic and aspartic acids.
4. Complex Tons of Thorium -
The highly-charged pceitive lon, Th+‘h, has & strong tendency to form com=-
plex ions with enions which may be present in solution. Some familiarity with
the more common of these complex ions is required for a proper u.nderstanding of
tbe behavior of thorium lm ion exchange sepa.ra.tions, in the extraction of thori-
um into organic solvents and so on., Quantitatlive measurements which have been
made on the equilibrium constants for complex ion formations are summarized in
Table 2.
TABLE 2 COMPLEX IORS OF THORIUM
(Reprinted from Katz and Sesborg p.57, reference 5)
Complexing Reaction - Ionic K I Ref'-
Agent 8trength _ erences
c1L” 01" = e *3 ' 0.5 2.2h a
0.7 1.78 a
1.0 1.53 a
2.0 1.21 e
4.0 1.70 a
6.0 2.1 a
mn*te2cT = Thcféz 2.0 0.1 a
Yo - 0.1k a
6.0 0.55 a
301" = Tao1tt 2.0 0.2 . a -
4.0 0.10 a
6.0 0.35 a
e = ThCL,, : k.0 0.018 a
N05 Th*"‘mo; = Th(NO3)+3 0.5 L.73 b
: ' 2.97 2.83
Th+h+2£0§ = Th(NO3);2 5.97 1.4 c
c10; '1'h+4+01o; - 'I‘h(ClO3)+3 ~ 0.5 1.84 b
TABLE 2 (Cont'd.)
Complexing Reaction Tonic K Ref
Agent ' Strength erences
Bro; Th+h+Br05 = Th(Br03)+3 0.5 6.4 b
‘I‘h+h'+2:Br05 - Th(BrOB)'éz 0.5 8.2 b
C1CE,COOH Th+h+ClCHZCOOH = Th(C1CH,C00 R 0.5 1.33 b
C1,CHCOCH Th+h+CIZCBJOOH = Th(Clzcacoo)+3+H+ 0.5 5.7h b
Th“‘+2012011c003 = Th(Clchcoo);2+zn* 0.5 12.7 b
C1.,CCO0H Th+h+013CC00H = Th(0130000)+3+]1+ 0.5 8.23 b
Th*l-tec13ccoon = Tl:\(c13ccoo)'2’2+13H+ 0.5 26.7 b
1'0_;’ Th*l‘qo; = Th( 103)+3 0.5 "{.6x_'|.0i b
Th+l++2105 = Th(IO3)£2 0.5 6.2x10
Th+h'+310; = Th( :ro3)3JL 0.5 1.4x107
- +i - ++ -+
EOM_ Th +E0h‘ = ThSOh +H 2.0 159 .C
Th*'!f-zmo; = Th(80,, ) +2E" 2.0 2850 c
'1'?:1*"‘“+215|.°..o,:L = Th(rsohsoh)‘” +E" 2.0 800 c
HaPoh_ Th#'t+H3PO,+ = Th(H3POL)+J+ 2.0 T8 ¢
Th+h+H3P01|_ = -1'1:1(15[2?01‘)"34[+ 2.0 150 c
Th+4+ZH3POh_ = Th(HzP°hH£°1+)+3+H+ 2.0 1400 c
Th*‘l‘+zna1=oh = Th(H,P0, )5 +2H" 2.0 8000 c
EF Tt EF = ThETO4E 0.5 sx10° o
T4 2HF - ThF§2+ZH+ 0.5 2.9,‘10; e
e 3EF = ThF3+3H+ 0.5 9.4x10 d
CH,COCH, COCH, Tht*+EAcAc = Th(ache)t+E" 0.0l 3. 7107 e
Tt +2BAcAc = Th(AcAc)*Zr2E" 0.0L 7.3kx10%?
T, 3pAcAe = Th(AcAc) +3H" 0.0L 5.93x10%°
Th“AEAcAc = -Th(AcAc)ll_+1+3+ 0.01 5.3Tx1025
a. W.C. Waggener and R.W. Stoughton, J. Phys. Chem
. 56, 1-5 (1952).
b. R.A. Dey Jr. and R.W. Stoughton, J. Am. Chem. Soc. T2, 5662-66 (1950).
c. E.L. Zebroskl, H.W. Alter, and F.K. Heumann, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. T3,
5646-50(1951) -
d. H.W. Dodgen and G.K. Rollefson, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 71, 2600-7 (1949).
e. J. Rydberg, Acta Chem. Scand. 4, 1503-22 (1950); Arkiv for Keml 5,
413-23 (1953). -
A large number of other complex ions are known although not much quantita-
tive information 1s avallable on the strength of the complexes. Ions derived
from meny organic acids such es cltrate, phthalate, maleate, succinate, malo-
nete lon and ethylenediaminetetrascetic (called EDTA or versene) form a series
of complex compounds or lons with thorium, The soluble EDTA-Complex of thorium .
forms the basis of an excellent tdtrimetric determination of small amounts of
thoriumll’lz. It 18 of great significance to radlochemistry that thorium forms
a negatively-charged nitrate complex in nitriec acid solutions greater than 3
molar in concentration. This is discussed further in connection with anion
exchange methods.
In connectlon with complex ion formation we may mention briefly the hydroly-
sis of thorium ion. In acidlic solution throughout the entire range below pH3
hydrolysis of Th+1|. is negligible. At higher pH values there is extensive hydroly-
8le. There is a consldersble disagreement in the published literature on the |
products of hydrolysis end a number of mononucdlear and polynuclear complexes
have been postulated. For interesting experimental studies and theoretical in-
terpretation of the hydrolysls of 'I'h+h see Krans and Holmbergl3 and Ei]_'l.énlh’ 15.
5. Chelste Compounds of Thorium
A few 1,3 diketones form chelate complexes of thorium which are readily ex-
tractable from agqueous solution into organic solvente. This fact forms the ba-
gls of a wildely used method for the radiochemical purification of tracer thor-
ium, namely the extraction into benzene of the thenoyltrifluorcacetore acid com-
plex of thorium which 1s discussed in section 6. Before discussing this speci-
fic eystem, it will be worthwhile to review briefly the other known complexes
of this type which thorlium forms.
The very strong and rather volatile complex of thorium.with ecetylacetone
has been knwon for many yea.rs.ls In a 1,3 diketone complex of this type, four
molecules of the organic compound react with the Th'm ion to form a neutral
complex. Thorium acetylacetonate, like the other metal acetylacetonates,
poeges a cyclie structure with the metal incorporated as part of a six-membered
ring. Rydberng has made a particuarly careful study on the complex formatlon
between thorium end acetylacetone and of the extraction of the complex 1lnto
organic solvents. Other 1,3 diketones which form similar complex compounds mich
more stable toward acidlc solutions are trifluoroacetylacetone, thenoyltrifluoro-
-2
acetylacetone, benzoylacetone and dibenzoyl 11149.'t.]:ua.1:LelB 0._ A comprehensive 1n-
2
vestigation of thorium chelate complexes was carrled out by Dyrssen 1. Some of
his remults are quoted i1n Teble 3 where the complexing constants of the proton
and thorium complexes of several chelating agente are given.
Thorium forms complex compounds with salicylic acid, methoxybenzolic acid
and cinnamie acidzz. The thorium-salicylate complex extracted lnto methyl
isobutyl ketone has salicyclic aclid assoclated with 1t and mmy have the formila
Th(HA)h-HzA. Cowan®2® developed a procedure for thorium analysis based on the
extraction of the thorium salicylate complex into a mixed solvent of chloroform
" and ethyl acetate. ‘ |
Cupferron (nitrosophenylhydroxylamine) forms & complex which can be ex-
tracted into cholorform. Thorium forms a complex with quinolinol which is sol-
uble in orgaenic solvents.23 The thorlum complex wilth the reagent, thorin, 1s
widely used in a colorimetric analytical method.23a’23b
TABLE 3 THORIUM COMPLEXES OF SOME CHELATING AGENTS. (Dr:rflsenZJ)
Chelating Agent: DKa 1/4 log X
(note 1)
Acetyl acetone 8.82 -2.85
Thenoyltrifluoroacetone 6.23 . +0.0k4
1-nitroso-2-naphthol T.63 -0.41
2-nitroso-l-naphthol 7.24 +0.05
Tropolone 6.71 +0.52
Cupferron 4.16 +1.11
N-phenylbenzohydroxamic acild 8.15 -0.17
8 Hydroxy quinoline (oxine) 9.66 -1.78
5 Methyl oxine 9.93 -2.5
5 Acetyl oxine T-75 -1.0
5,7 Dichloro oxine T4 =0.22
Cinpamic acld 4,27
notel K= [MAnJ orgfif]n [M]n[HA]grg , where MAn = uncharged complex;
[BA]= ec1d form 6f the chelating agent.
6. Extraction of the TTA-Complex of Thorium into Organic Solvents
Many of the chelate complexes mentioned in the last section of this report
are soluble in organic solvents. By sultable adjustment of reagent concentre~
tions and acldity, thorium cen be cleanly separated from conteminating ione by
such an extraction procedure, We single out for special attention the complex
formed with a-thenoyltrifluoroacetone, (called for convenience, TTA), which
has been more widely used in rediochemlistry then any of the others. Some of the
reasons for this are the gtabllity of the reagent toward acidic solution, the
favorable Keto-enol equilibrium in the remgent, the strength of the thorlum com-
plex in slightly acldic solutions and the moderate solubllity of the complex in
such solvents as benzene, chloroform and ketones.
Hagemannah studied the zcld dependence of the extraction of trace quantities
of thorium, ectinium and other elememts into an 0.2M solution of TTA in benzeme.
A typlcal curve 1s shown in figure 1. The extraction of thorium is essentially
quantitative ebove pHland drops rapldly in solutions of higher acidity. The
acld dependence is fourth power so that rather sensitive control of the extrac-
tiofi can be made by control of the acldity. This control 1s highly useful since
thorium mey easily be separasted from elements of lower lonic charge such es the
alkall elements, the alkgline earths and even the rare earth elements by extrac-
tion of thorium 1n the pH range of 1 to 2. Elements which extract more readlly
than thorium are left in the benzene phase when the thorium is later removed by
contact with an agueous solution. of sl ightly lower pH. The chief lomns which are
extracted more strongly than thorium Iin solutions of acidity greaster than pHL
are zirconium (IV), hafnium (IV), plutonium (IV), neptunium(IV), iron III, and
protactinium (V). These ions show high partition coefficients into the organic
phese for solutions as strongly acidic as 1 molar or greater.
Further control of thorium extvrectlon can be achieved by chenging the con-
centration of TTA or by using another solvent In place of benzene. The presence
of ions which form strong complexes with thorium (see Table 2) interferes with
the extraction of thorium; therefore, it is best to perform the extraction from
S
— 100F
2 i Th(lV) Ac (I11)
o 80
|—
xX 60 '
w MU-9899
- 40+
w 20F
(&
ES I i 1 ! i 1
a i 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
pH
Figure 1 Extraction of trace amounts of actinium end thorium
from a dilute nitric acid solution by an equal volume of an 0.25 M
gdolution of TTA in benzene as a function of pH.
a8 dilute nitric acld, perchloric acid or hydrochloric acid solution. Most of
the complex ion formation constants listed in Table 2 were measured by noting
the changes in the extractability of the thorium-TTA complex into benzeme when
various anions were added. to the agquecus phase. Hence the references quoted in
Teble 2 can be consulted for very specific information on the extraction of thori-
um in the presence of complexing anions.
TTA extraction of thorlum is an important step in several of the procedures
written down in SBection V below.
Thorium may be separsted from uranium when both are present in small con-
centrations 1if the solution co.nfa.ins no great quantity of neutral salts, but
the acldity mist be edjusted carefully, There are better methods for meking
this particular separation. The extraction of tracer thorium from concentrated
golutions of uranium is not satisfactory beceause of the formation of insoluble
uranium complex compounds at the interfece and it is necessary to remove the
bulk of the urmalum by some prelimlinary step.
In the isolation of small emountes of thorium from a complx initial mixture
of elements TTA extraction provides an excellent final step. Carrier precipitates
such as lanthanum fluoride and zirconium lodate may be used to remove the bulk
of the impurities and the finel purificaetion as well as the elimlnation of the
carrier material, may be effected by a final TTA-extraction cycle.
The solubility of the thorium-TTA complex In benzene 18 rather small so
that large volumes of solutlon are required to handle bulk amounts (gram amounts)
of thorium. Some .wor]a:ersz5 report good results with the reagent, 1-(3,4 dichloro-
phenyl) - &,k4,5,5,6,6,6 heptafluoro-1,3 hexanldione which forme a thorium complex
with a coneldersbly higher solubility in benzene. Unfortunately, this reagent
is not avallsble commercially. With this ‘reagent 20 grems of thorium can be dis-
solved 1n 100 millileters of Cfllh_ compared to 0.3 grems of thorium as the TTA-
complex.
T. Extraction of Thorium Into Organic Solvents o
The extrzctability of thorium from esgqueous solutlions irto organic solventa
has been studled for dozens of representative solvents of all types. Most aof
these studies have been concerned with hydrochloric acid systems, nitric acid
syetems or mixed nitric acid - neutral nitrate salt systems. A great deal of
the information on the extraction of thorium, urenium and plutonium was origj.-
nally published in dlessified repfirts of the Manhattan Project or of the Atcmic
Bnergy Commission or of the governmental lsboratories of Canada and Great Britain
and France. This information is now declassifled, but there has never been a
complete systematic covermge of the basic chemistry in bocks &nd Journals readi-
ly avallable in any sclentific laboratory. Solvent extractlon processes have
been developed for the recovery of thorium from monazite sands, for the separa-
tlon of U°33 from neutron irradiated thorfum, for the recovery of the irraiisted
thorium for reuse, and for othefi:- .purpoaes. In this brief review, we conflne
our rema.rks to the chief solvents and the pflnc:l.pa.l effects of experimental
conditions of the laboratory scale treatment of small or tracer quaht:l.ties of
thorium,
Ethyl ether ig often used to purify uranium. If the agueous phase ia
slightly acidic with nitric acld (perhaps .0l to .05 Molar) and highly selted
with a neutral nitrate such as amnnium, cdlclum or megnesium fiitrate, then
12
uranium ieg reedlly extracted into ethyl ether leaving nearly all lmpurities in-
cluding thorium in the aquecus phase. Thorium will not extract into ethyl ether
unless the concentration of acid ard neutral salts in the aqueous phase is so
high that numerous other Impurites would also extract.
Methyl iscbutyl ketone wlll extract thorium with a distribution coeffi-
clent ae high as 9 (organic/aq_ueoua) provided the nitric acld concentration
of the agueous phase 1s malntgined at 1M to 3M and if, in addition, a high
concentration of such strong salting egents as calelum, magnesium or aluminum
nitrate 1s maintelned. At the Towa State College in Ames Iowa, large quantities
of thorium were purified from monazlte sands by a process which included a sol-
vent extraction separation of thorium fram rare eexrth impurities 26. The so0l-
vent was hexone and the aquecus phase feed solution was 3 Molar in calcilum ni-
trate and 3 Molgr in nitric acid, _
Rydberg and Bernstrim’| have studied the distribution of Th(IV), U(VI),
Pu(IV), PU(VI), Zr(IV), Ca(II}, La(III) and mwo3 between methyl isobutyl ketone
and agueocus solutions of nltric acid and calcium nitrate of varying composition.
Figure 2 teken from thelr work shows the maln feamtures of the extractlon of
theee 1lons. A 1955 Geneva Conference peper of BrucezTa discusees the extractlion
of flssion products into hexone.
Pentaether (dlbutoxytetraethylene glycol) will extract thorium from
equeous nitrate soclutions under moderate salting conditionasz. For example,
3 and 1M or greater in calclum
nltrate are removed to the extent of 90 percent or more from the agqueous phase
by an equal volume of this solvent. Fifty percent is removed from s IM B.ND3
solution and 80 percent from an BM BNJ3 solution by an equal volume of solvent.
If the agueous phese ig 1M in H'.NO3 arzag saturated with emmonium nitrate, the
extraction 1s quantitative. Pappard ~ hes reported the use of pentaether 1n
the purification of lbnium (Th230) from pltchblende resldues. He states that
90 percent of the thorium is extracted from a solution &M in “Eum3 and 0.3 M
in HFO_ into an equal volume of solvent consisting of a mixture of pentaether
(2 volumes) and diethylether (1 volume). Under these conditipne less than 1
percent of yttrium snd the rare earths are extracted.See alpo analytical method
of nefigseffgfi oxtde [ (CB,), C = CH-CO-CH3] has been reported to be & useful sol-
vent for thorlum. Levine and Grima.ldizg have used 1t in an analytical procedure
tracer amounts of thorium in a solutlon Zy_ in HRNO
for the determination of thorium in thorium ores. The ore sample is decomposed
by fusion wilth a mixture of NaF 'KZSZO'T' Thorium is precipltated as the oxalate.
The oxalate preclpitate 1s dissolved 1n nitric eclid end the solution 1s pre-
pared for solvent extrection by edjusting the ZE[BOB concentration to 1.2 Molar
and edding eluminum nitrate to 2.5 Molar, The solution is contacted with an
equal volume of mesityl oxlde which extracts the thorium quantitatively and
separates it from nearly all impurities including rare earths. Traces of
13
-
=
L
o
L
Lo MU - 16989
LJ
o
o
<
o
=
=
<
o
K o= 000"
1 1 ] |
4 5 6
| M HNO,
Figure 2 Solvent extrection data for methyl isobutyl ketone.
The distribution ratios of U, Pu, Th, Zr, La and Ca as functions
of the equllibrium concentration of HN03 in the mqueous phase,
Concentration of Ca(NO is 3.5 to 4.0 Molar. Data by -Ry'd'berg
w27
and Bernatrom.
3)2
rare earths are removed from the solvent by three separate washes with e wash
solution containing HNO &nd Al(ND ) . The thorium is stripped from the washed
- solvent with weter. Thorium is precipita'ted as the oxalate and ignited to
Tth, in which form 1t 1s weighed,
Hiller and Mertin3® have used mesityl oxlde to extract thorium eway from
rare earth fission products in a thorium target solution. The thorium metal
was dissolved in HC1 with a small amount of fluosilicate lon present to clear
up the solution. The solution was seturated with A1(®O )3 and the thorium was
extra.cted. by contecting the solution with mesityl o:d.d.e.
Marechal-Cornil and Picciotto3 used mesityl oxide for the quantitative
.ex't.ra.ction of thorium, bismth and polonium from a mixture of natural radlo-
elements present in concentrations 10_9 grams per c¢.c, The solution was sat-
urated with Al(N03)3. Redium and lead did not extract.
Tributyl Phosphate (THP) 1e a wldely used solvent in the industrial scale
recovery of uranium and thorium from ores, or the purification of urenium, thor-
ium or plutonium from reactor fuel elements. Some idea of the scope of 1ts use
4
32-34
can be obteined by consulting some general references on process chemistry.
The mdjustment of egqueous phase composition for the optimum radiochemlcal
purification of thorium depends greatly on the nature of the impurities present.
The principal heavy elements or fission products which show high extractability
into TBP are the following:
thorium (IV) < £¢ptunium (I¥) < plutonium (IV)
plutonium (VI) < neptunium (VI) < uranium {VI)
protactinium (V)
cerium (IV) hafnium (IV) zirconium {IV)
rare earths (ITI) (considersbly less extracteble than
above under most cond:l.'l:.ions).
RuNo (III)
TABLE 4 BASIC REPERXNCES ON THE EXTRAOTIOF OF THORIUM, OTHER HEAVY ELEMENTS
AND THE RARE BARTHS INTO TBP
Tri-n-butyl Phosphate as an Extracting Bolvent for Inorganic Nitrates,
I. Zirconium nitrate
35. K. Alcock, F. C. Bedford, W. H. Hardwlick and H.A.C. McKay,
J. Inorganic and Nuclear Chem. L4, 100, 1957.
II. Yttrium and the lower lanthanide nitrates
36. D. Bcargill, K. Alcock, J. M. Fletcher, E. Hesford, and H.A.C.
McKey. J. Inorg. Fucl. Chem. L4, 304, 1957
ITT. The plutonium nitrates _
37. G. F. Best, H.A.C. McKay and P.R. Woodgate, J. Inorg., Rucl.
Chem., k%, 315, 1957
IV. Thorium nitrate
38. E. Hesford, H.A.C. McKay and D. Scargill, J. Inorg. and Fucl.
Chem. 4, 321, 1957
An excellent overall view of the extraction of these elements from hydro-
chloric or nitric acid systems of varylng composition into an undiluted or
diluted THP solvent phase is presented in the articles listed in Table L.
The high extractabillty of thorium into undiluted TBP from hydrochloric
acid and nitric acld systems are given in figures 3 and 4. Thorium nitrate 1s
mich more extractable when most of the nitrie acid in the esgueous phase 18 re-
placed by some nitrate salt such as sodium nitrate, caleium nitrate or alumlmum
nitraete. Thls 1s drematically shown 1n Taeble 5 where some date taken from a
publicetion of H.A.C. MKay are presented. The maln reason for the difference
1s that the neutral nitrate salts are not soluble in TBP whereas BNQ3 forma a
seoluble complex with TBP.
Bernstrom and Rydberghl have studied the effect of the replacement of HN03
with calcium nitrate on the extraction of thorium by undiluted tributyl phosphute.
An approximate summary of thelr results 1s glven in Table 6. Some of the impor-
0.}
0.01
0.001