new Keycloak/keycloak Provider dose not work

[AchimGrolimund]

Thank you for reporting an issue.

I made the upgrade from the old mrparkers/keycloak 4.4.0 to keycloak/keycloak 4.5.0
but i can not run the plan/apply

Based on this PR: #1356

Reproduce:

1. upgrade versions.tf:

terraform {
  required_providers {
    keycloak = {
      source = "keycloak/keycloak"
      version = "4.5.0"
    }
  }
}

2. run upgrade commands:

tofu state replace-provider mrparkers/keycloak keycloak/keycloak
# Successful

tofu init -upgrade
# Successful

tofu plan

Planning failed. OpenTofu encountered an error while generating this plan.

╷
│ Error: Missing required attribute
│ 
│   on provider["registry.opentofu.org/mrparkers/keycloak"] with no configuration line 1:
│   (source code not available)
│ 
│ The attribute "client_id" is required, but no definition was found.
╵
╷
│ Error: Missing required attribute
│ 
│   on provider["registry.opentofu.org/mrparkers/keycloak"] with no configuration line 1:
│   (source code not available)
│ 
│ The attribute "url" is required, but no definition was found.
╵

i have a file named: terraform.tf (same directory):

terraform {
  backend "s3" {
    ...
  }
}

provider "keycloak" {
  client_id     = var.terraform_client_id
  client_secret = var.terraform_client_secret
  url           = var.rhbk_base_url
}

OpenTofu Version

➜  tofu version
OpenTofu v1.8.7
on linux_amd64
+ provider registry.opentofu.org/hashicorp/external v2.3.4
+ provider registry.opentofu.org/hashicorp/null v3.2.3
+ provider registry.opentofu.org/hashicorp/time v0.12.1
+ provider registry.opentofu.org/keycloak/keycloak v4.5.0
+ provider registry.opentofu.org/mrparkers/keycloak v4.5.0

### OpenTofu Configuration Files

```hcl
# This file is maintained automatically by "tofu init".
# Manual edits may be lost in future updates.

provider "registry.opentofu.org/hashicorp/external" {
  version = "2.3.4"
  hashes = [
    "h1:saRbzhRhYh4urj+ARe8vIB0mlRspy6E/fPSyvwqjUW8=",
    "zh:0e5eb3513d6ad5cc3196799a6e413c6a9c0b642ba6d8f84fc11efa48f58358a4",
    "zh:1658beae42b4614d4009a3191710c86571ccf1dc526c4bac520a87ab701dd2e9",
    "zh:28d937c13e90c170fc1e4b726a9bcf113aade53b95b3eccd335cd9eaba8acff5",
    "zh:2ac19917bb83233f24391d4cbaf301bb6ec14013d3b7f93bdf64823280622daa",
    "zh:3263d1808fc5252d586a9aa98d89086c912f53e1a3dc43bc5306364b358f04fa",
    "zh:463469836637342495e22a936ef9ab3c8ab2fb47eb0fae09c346d63f3331af59",
    "zh:53398a27492cd11f61b2f24c2601c12f50c39da32b90fd25aed7011a1e25a225",
    "zh:5a44cfbcef52fd3c970144a69a934cab320bd3bb57939ae4682fc516783e2996",
    "zh:65edb579d9d0dac42e77728d81da6e85ea30d3fe8f2cb6e5db82602ee8afa17e",
    "zh:f2edd3027b7ae0d31a690fd5dcdcd22b467b4f1e045f84f2bc88289353ef9a5b",
  ]
}

provider "registry.opentofu.org/hashicorp/null" {
  version = "3.2.3"
  hashes = [
    "h1:LF8arSzHfhbyQSFtTMTYEqCM34klzrbAQBJMHYCs9d8=",
    "zh:1d57d25084effd3fdfd902eca00020b34b1fb020253b84d7dd471301606015ac",
    "zh:65b7f9799b88464d9c2ec529713b7f52ea744275b61a8dc86cdedab1b2dcb933",
    "zh:80d3e9c95b7b4ae7c54005cd127cae82e5c53d2b7023ef24c147337bac9dadd9",
    "zh:841b60c07683e4bf456799ccd718896fdafdcc2c49252ae09967f2e74d8c8a03",
    "zh:8fa1c592a9c78222e35713c6edb3f1f818a4c6f3524a30a209f0a7e919827b68",
    "zh:bb795cc1429e09466840c09d39a28edf1db5070b1ec76822fc1173906a264572",
    "zh:da1784818a89bea29dfe660632f0060a7a843e4e564d74435fbeca002b0f7d2a",
    "zh:f409bf21b1cdaa6dac47cd79806f3d93f67e9507fe4dbf33b0165335f53bc2e1",
    "zh:fbea7a1ff84b430ba9594698e93196d81d03e4036de3d1cafccb2a96d5b38581",
    "zh:fbf0c84663a7e85881388d7d71ac862184f05fbf2d17ecf76bc5d3d7503ea260",
  ]
}

provider "registry.opentofu.org/hashicorp/time" {
  version = "0.12.1"
  hashes = [
    "h1:PnOB6IAQJoYi/r3iUH7Hml2c2zFrIzHksQsrK3VPjSI=",
    "zh:50a9b67d5f5f42adbdb7712f67858aa64b5670070f6710751239b535fb48a4df",
    "zh:5a846fae035e363aed75b966d64a56f3489a38083e8407aaa656730437f53ed7",
    "zh:6767f1fc8a679b48eaa4cd114da0d8185fb3546375f3a0fb3728f10fa3dbc551",
    "zh:85d3da407c828bf057cbc0e86c75ef3d0f9f74a73c4ea1b4aef18e33f41092b1",
    "zh:9180721325139431112c638f5382a740ff219782f81d6346cdff5bccc418a43f",
    "zh:9ba9989f905a64db1409a9a57649549c89c7aedfb55ae399a7fa9411aafaadac",
    "zh:b3d9e7afb6a742e9be0541bc434b00d849fdfab0b4b859ceb0296c26c541af15",
    "zh:c87da712d718acd9dd03f544b020c320699cb29df197be4f74783e3c3d80fc17",
    "zh:cb1abe07638ef6d7b41d0e86dfb12d60a513aca3395a5da7191947f7459821dd",
    "zh:ecff2e823ef49eda03663fa8ee8bdc17d27cd419dbdacbf1719f38812dbf417e",
  ]
}

provider "registry.opentofu.org/keycloak/keycloak" {
  version     = "4.5.0"
  constraints = "4.5.0"
  hashes = [
    "h1:SaRSw74s//z4y2VybrIcx3GaIUQKcBcVGyYzhPVKq1g=",
    "zh:08c76d5000a2f8683577bf3fa5529584742e5f06bc06cf42ea8b05c94297cf7f",
    "zh:24ade48d62a67c65a64b425a23aa473eff0fdecae628a7272dbd027e7d1fb992",
    "zh:24c2c7d21f3e85256eed0f2601e9cbaf826867cf05c942f93d8c2a396cf3b1a3",
    "zh:2a4114f9f83f2c3286488773473bb67159dfd831b8b05076cfa5b54c84aa6111",
    "zh:3abbd8c4ec23b25a1083d4fee53f12c0b058906c87bb31d887d62dad354b3edf",
    "zh:5ed4fb36fb260b4af613e5e389710551cd6acec4b7b970de3dceb064d9e92036",
    "zh:718f6265f7cbefb72c65d32141c0e0816219b35dea3f978f2c9e441bc9f3b42b",
    "zh:72abedcdeccb82bfa5ea07fc54edd3d088fda9b3619d99f2dea81ba5b12a38e1",
    "zh:78c5a6cfc8789134f8f1c997bb8731395872ba0d4bc7f7df010e53ba52b92fe2",
    "zh:792206341f0ffcfad5b732fe938d93b911283088d7c2dc14be28ae8879fa9407",
    "zh:82ed201fe929d42b13725ae4e196b8842995a9ac261914b6721b2cf7c7c05a26",
    "zh:98ce3081a3a4998d793fd4ea01b386efa7076533aff0b055f93395955619ebfb",
    "zh:b91e4a911c30f0a5e929a34f9bbfc67cb8e5aa3b0a62633e4cfa44186ca10420",
    "zh:c39ac1504df522384186a446da485c906517c5f312ef4e321a6ad4c30b019e30",
    "zh:cbe2b76fc69f688500c0381160dbea6537add3d18cc7b622f81650a9c9af162d",
    "zh:e6b173a1e4ffa855d0a222c54e89efe0be648df3a29d39c66286132fa2e0a35e",
    "zh:eb7c90edaef4b97e86cb4b9ba8edfff49732f97eb60cf5acef4d790bed032bb3",
  ]
}

provider "registry.opentofu.org/mrparkers/keycloak" {
  version     = "4.5.0"
  constraints = ">= 4.4.0, < 5.0.0"
  hashes = [
    "h1:SaRSw74s//z4y2VybrIcx3GaIUQKcBcVGyYzhPVKq1g=",
    "zh:08c76d5000a2f8683577bf3fa5529584742e5f06bc06cf42ea8b05c94297cf7f",
    "zh:24ade48d62a67c65a64b425a23aa473eff0fdecae628a7272dbd027e7d1fb992",
    "zh:24c2c7d21f3e85256eed0f2601e9cbaf826867cf05c942f93d8c2a396cf3b1a3",
    "zh:2a4114f9f83f2c3286488773473bb67159dfd831b8b05076cfa5b54c84aa6111",
    "zh:3abbd8c4ec23b25a1083d4fee53f12c0b058906c87bb31d887d62dad354b3edf",
    "zh:5ed4fb36fb260b4af613e5e389710551cd6acec4b7b970de3dceb064d9e92036",
    "zh:718f6265f7cbefb72c65d32141c0e0816219b35dea3f978f2c9e441bc9f3b42b",
    "zh:72abedcdeccb82bfa5ea07fc54edd3d088fda9b3619d99f2dea81ba5b12a38e1",
    "zh:78c5a6cfc8789134f8f1c997bb8731395872ba0d4bc7f7df010e53ba52b92fe2",
    "zh:792206341f0ffcfad5b732fe938d93b911283088d7c2dc14be28ae8879fa9407",
    "zh:82ed201fe929d42b13725ae4e196b8842995a9ac261914b6721b2cf7c7c05a26",
    "zh:98ce3081a3a4998d793fd4ea01b386efa7076533aff0b055f93395955619ebfb",
    "zh:b91e4a911c30f0a5e929a34f9bbfc67cb8e5aa3b0a62633e4cfa44186ca10420",
    "zh:c39ac1504df522384186a446da485c906517c5f312ef4e321a6ad4c30b019e30",
    "zh:cbe2b76fc69f688500c0381160dbea6537add3d18cc7b622f81650a9c9af162d",
    "zh:e6b173a1e4ffa855d0a222c54e89efe0be648df3a29d39c66286132fa2e0a35e",
    "zh:eb7c90edaef4b97e86cb4b9ba8edfff49732f97eb60cf5acef4d790bed032bb3",
  ]
}

[abstractionfactory]

Hi @AchimGrolimund thank you for the issue. The Keycloak provider is maintained here. Please raise this issue with the provider maintainers as the OpenTofu maintainers have no ability to fix this bug.

[AchimGrolimund]

Hey @abstractionfactory okay i wil do that. i was not sure, if this is an issue comming from the REgestry or from tofu.

thanks for pointing this out.