-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 25
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Missing isospin for h(1)(1415) ? #486
Comments
|
Hi, without looking into details, |
Hey both, thanks for the message. I'm over-busy today and will look carefully but indeed the PDG info so far provides
Most likely the PDF ".mcd" we rely on does not provide I, and we do not "add the info by hand". I put this in quote because we do add a bunch of info ourselves in the package, but care is needed. Note that the 2023 update from the PDG is probably going to be out soon-ish, typically in May. We will see what updates that has :-). Back asap with more details. |
FYI, some preview for the upcoming PDG API is here |
Thanks a lot for the feedback, @eduardo-rodrigues and @mmikhasenko!
This is worth an issue in itself 😏 |
Hey folks, so I did a bit of digging. Indeed the source of the missing info is 2-fold:
For reference here are the h mesons in the "table":
How important and/or urgent is it for you to have the particle with isospin information available? I could make a little update to the package for that. |
Nice, thanks for the thorough investigation!
Not that urgent, I posted a solution for modifying the particle database in the downstream package :) |
Thank you @mmikhasenko for the link to that PDG presentation. Really useful! I had been in chats with Juerg in the past and it seems I should talk to him again - was easier the one time he was at CERN. BTW, let me know if you have any thoughts on the "business" (by email if you prefer) as it will be useful for sure. Actually some of the material is more relevant for the DecayLanguage package. |
I guess you suggested to do OK, so not urgent. This being said you gave me more motivation to try and find time. Did one ever say that user feedback really is important :)! |
BTW, by the time I move to improved tables I am hoping to provide more info, maybe a notebook, so that users can more easily contribute and help. |
Could it be that$h_1(1415)$ is missing isospin? PDG for reference:
https://pdglive.lbl.gov/Particle.action?init=0&node=M109&home=MXXX005
particle/src/particle/data/particle2022.csv
Line 337 in 817a0f6
particle/src/particle/data/particle2022.csv
Line 2 in 817a0f6
Bumped into it while investigating ComPWA/qrules#165
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: