Error when compiling Mohr-Coulomb Mfront files from the tutorial in MFront gallery #79

gitable05 · 2022-01-14T09:02:12Z

gitable05
Jan 14, 2022

Hi,

This question is first posted in FEniCS discourse and it was suggested that I post it here. After the day of posting, I sort of found a solution, but I would still like to bring this to your attention. Thanks!

--

I am interested in doing simulations in FEniCS with Mohr-Coulomb criterion. I followed this tutorial 1 which implements a von Mises criterion with MFront. Here, I successfully compiled the MFront file and ran the sample problem. Now, I moving on to Mohr-Coulomb criterion with this tutorial 2. There are two code blocks that I saved into MFront files. The first one was in the section "Simplification of the MFront file : use of TFEL/Material/MohrCoulombYieldCriterion.hxx file" and other one is in the section "Simplification of the MFront file : use of the StandardElastoViscoPlasticity brick". Both return this error when compiling:

In file included from ~/codes/tfel/master/install-661d98cec3cd9c6059b31210be1dbe72e447f11d/include/TFEL/Material/MohrCoulombYieldCriterion.hxx:169,
from …/include/TFEL/Material/MohrCoulomAbboSloan3BehaviourData.hxx:40,
from …/include/TFEL/Material/MohrCoulomAbboSloan3.hxx:33,
from MohrCoulomAbboSloan3-generic.cxx:27:
~/codes/tfel/master/install-661d98cec3cd9c6059b31210be1dbe72e447f11d/include/TFEL/Material/MohrCoulombYieldCriterion.ixx: In lambda function:
~/codes/tfel/master/install-661d98cec3cd9c6059b31210be1dbe72e447f11d/include/TFEL/Material/MohrCoulombYieldCriterion.ixx:110:56: error: ‘sin_angle’ was not declared in this scope
110 | const auto term2 = sign * p.sin_lodeT + isqrt3 * sin_angle * p.cos_lodeT;
| ^~~~~~~~~
compilation terminated due to -Wfatal-errors.
make: *** [Makefile.mfront:36: MohrCoulomAbboSloan3-generic.o] Error 1
callMake: can’t build target ‘all’
libraries building went wrong
Command was: make -C src -f Makefile.mfront all -s

Anyone who had the same problem? Any solution?

Thanks!

EDIT: I stitched the codes in the “Implementation” section of tutorial 2 to create the most explicit Mfront file without the simplifications in the next sections. I compiled it successfully but I have to include “@parameter pi = 3.14159265359;” and “constexpr auto local_zero_tolerance = real(1e-14);” as they were missing.

Answered by thelfer

Jan 14, 2022

@gitable05.

Please find attached three implementations. They all compile with TFEL-3.4.x although the third one may fail if C++-17 support is enabled (See Issue #80).

For TFEL-4.x versions, it seems that PR #5 messed things up and broke the MohrCoulombStressCriterion.ixx file. We will treat this in Issue #81. Sorry for the inconvenience.

All in all, those implementations are not robust as the normal may strongly oscillate between two iterations, so it need to be slightly modified using a small unpublished trick. Just send me an email at tfel-contact@cea.fr, and I'll send you a proper implementation next week.

MohrCoulomb.zip

View full answer

thelfer · 2022-01-14T09:19:28Z

thelfer
Jan 14, 2022
Maintainer

Hi @gitable05,

Thanks for you interest to MFront.

Would you attach you implementations ?

Best,
Thomas

BTW, did you used mgis.fenics (https://thelfer.github.io/mgis/web/mgis_fenics.html)

0 replies

thelfer · 2022-01-14T13:34:11Z

thelfer
Jan 14, 2022
Maintainer

@gitable05.

Please find attached three implementations. They all compile with TFEL-3.4.x although the third one may fail if C++-17 support is enabled (See Issue #80).

For TFEL-4.x versions, it seems that PR #5 messed things up and broke the MohrCoulombStressCriterion.ixx file. We will treat this in Issue #81. Sorry for the inconvenience.

All in all, those implementations are not robust as the normal may strongly oscillate between two iterations, so it need to be slightly modified using a small unpublished trick. Just send me an email at tfel-contact@cea.fr, and I'll send you a proper implementation next week.

MohrCoulomb.zip

5 replies

gitable05 Jan 14, 2022
Author

@thelfer

Thank you for the response and the files.

BTW, did you used mgis.fenics (https://thelfer.github.io/mgis/web/mgis_fenics.html)

I am yet to work on this but I will sure look at mgis.fenics. My plan is to first modify the tutorial with von Mises + MFront to instead have Mohr-Coulomb model. Hopefully, I can get that to work and then base my intended project on that.

Best.

thelfer Jan 15, 2022
Maintainer

Again, the files that I sent you are useful for setting up your simulation. In practice, you'll need the modified ones.

thelfer Feb 2, 2022
Maintainer

@gitable05. For your information, Issue #81 is now closed. Let me know if you managed to use the files that I sent you.

gitable05 Feb 2, 2022
Author

@thelfer Yes, the file from OpenGeoSys works. I am also using mgis.fenics and encountered no issues yet.

Thanks!

thelfer Feb 3, 2022
Maintainer

@gitable05 Glad to hear that. If possible, do not hesitate to send me a nice picture for the TFEL/MFront twitter account with a little caption and credit.

s1966b · 2023-05-09T21:35:31Z

s1966b
May 9, 2023

@thelfer
Ref: Our email discussion and your kind reply dated 25/04/2023

Dear Thomas,
I apologise for my late response.

As you advised, I tried the command 'tfel-config --includes' (without quotes) which returned the following:
bash: tfel-config: command not found
After that I exported the TFEL-HOME variable as advised as follows:
export TFELHOME=/mfront340
Then I retried the same command. This time also it returned the same, i.e.,
bash: tfel-config: command not found.
For your convenience I am pasting here my original mail content to you for your kind perusal:
=====================================================================================(mail content begins)
a) I have mounted the directory /container/opt/salome_meca/Salome-V2021-s9/prerequisites/Mfront-TFEL340/ in a mount directory "/mfront340" in my singularity shell inside the container.
b) Then I have exported the paths as follows:
===========================================================================
Singularity> export PATH=/mfront340/bin:$PATH
Singularity> export LD_LIBRARY_PATH=/mfront340/lib:$LD_LIBRARY_PATH
Singularity> export LD_INCLUDE_PATH=/mfront340/include/TFEL-3.4.0:$LD_INCLUDE_PATH
===========================================================================
c) I thought that, the include directives written in different files such as "StressCriterion.hxx" etc. are fulfilled by this include path.
d) The directory structure for the mounted dir "/mfront340/" in the container is as follows:
d.1 /mfront340/include/TFEL-3.4.0/MFront/BehaviourBrick/
d.2 /mfront340/include/TFEL-3.4.0/TFEL/Material/ etc.
====================(mail content ends)
I would be grateful if you could further advise me on the matter so that I can compile the Mohr-Coulomb mfront files obtained from you.

Best regards and Thanks for your valuable time.

Sukumar

5 replies

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

There are two possibilities for bash: tfel-config: command not found:

The PATH are not set correctly
The version number is appended to the executable, so you shall use something like tfel-config-3.4.0. In your terminal, just type tfel-conf and use the completion to see if something is available

s1966b May 10, 2023

Dear Thomas
Thanks for your reply. I got the following output
Singularity> tfel-c tfel-check-3.4.0 tfel-config-3.4.0 tfel-config-bin-3.4.0 Singularity> tfel-config-3.4.0 --includes -I/home/salome/workspace/SALOME-MECA_V2021_PLATFORM/3/salome/prerequisites/install/Mfront-TFEL340/include/TFEL-3.4.0 Singularity>
Please advise how should I proceed now.

Best regards and thanks.

Sukumar

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

Does TFELHOME affects the output of tfel-config --includes ?

s1966b May 10, 2023

Unfortunately not. I got the following, i.e. same output from the 'tfel-config-3.4.0 --includes'.
Singularity> export TFELHOME=/mfront340 Singularity> tfel-config-3.4.0 --includes -I/home/salome/workspace/SALOME-MECA_V2021_PLATFORM/3/salome/prerequisites/install/Mfront-TFEL340/include/TFEL-3.4.0

Hope this helps to find the issue.

Thanks and regards.

Sukumar

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

That's unexpected. The code did not change in 3.4.x (compared to 3.4.0) and this works:

$ tfel-config --includes
-I/home/th202608/codes/tfel/tfel-3.4.x/install-python-3.7/include 
$ export TFELHOME=/tmp
$ tfel-config --includes
-I/tmp/include

s1966b · 2023-05-10T14:40:06Z

s1966b
May 10, 2023

Is the singularity container is an issue?
I had put this question in code-aster forum also, but did not get any advice relevant to the problem.
Should I try the latest container by EDF?

Regards

1 reply

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

I'll give the singularity container a try this evening

s1966b · 2023-05-10T15:16:54Z

s1966b
May 10, 2023

Thank you very much Thomas.

In fact I am using the container with code-aster 15.4 MPI version available at
"https://github.com/emefff/Code-Aster-MPI-in-Singularity-of-SM2021"
which is based on EDF container of Salome-meca-2021.

Would be waiting to hear from you.
Best regards and Thanks a lot for your time and patience.

Sukumar

1 reply

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

Ok. Apparently, the code_aster team replaced tfel-config-3.4.0 by a script that sets the TFELHOME variable internally. That's why setting TFELHOME has no effect. However, everything seems set correctly by default in the container:

$ tfel-config-3.4.0 --include-path
/opt/salome_meca/Salome-V2021-s9/prerequisites/Mfront-TFEL340/include/TFEL-3.4.0 
$ ls $(tfel-config-3.4.0 --include-path)

s1966b · 2023-05-11T13:52:18Z

s1966b
May 11, 2023

Dear Thomas,

Thank you very much for your time and advice.

In my unofficial container, the tfel-config --include-path is different and is a non existing directory. I think, that's where the problem lies.
I think, I will need to download the latest container from EDF and will need to compile code-aster MPI myself. Due to pre-occupations, I will be able to do it possibly in the next month only.
I will do the same and try again.
Will request your help if needed.

With warm regards and Best wishes

Sukumar

0 replies

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Error when compiling Mohr-Coulomb Mfront files from the tutorial in MFront gallery #79

{{title}}

Replies: 6 comments 12 replies

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{editor}}'s edit

{{editor}}'s edit

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

{{title}}

Select a reply

Error when compiling Mohr-Coulomb Mfront files from the tutorial in MFront gallery #79

gitable05 Jan 14, 2022

Replies: 6 comments · 12 replies

thelfer Jan 14, 2022 Maintainer

thelfer Jan 14, 2022 Maintainer

gitable05 Jan 14, 2022 Author

thelfer Jan 15, 2022 Maintainer

thelfer Feb 2, 2022 Maintainer

gitable05 Feb 2, 2022 Author

thelfer Feb 3, 2022 Maintainer

s1966b May 9, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023 Maintainer

s1966b May 10, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023 Maintainer

s1966b May 10, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023 Maintainer

s1966b May 10, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023 Maintainer

s1966b May 10, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023 Maintainer

s1966b May 11, 2023

gitable05
Jan 14, 2022

Replies: 6 comments 12 replies

thelfer
Jan 14, 2022
Maintainer

thelfer
Jan 14, 2022
Maintainer

gitable05 Jan 14, 2022
Author

thelfer Jan 15, 2022
Maintainer

thelfer Feb 2, 2022
Maintainer

gitable05 Feb 2, 2022
Author

thelfer Feb 3, 2022
Maintainer

s1966b
May 9, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

s1966b
May 10, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

s1966b
May 10, 2023

thelfer May 10, 2023
Maintainer

s1966b
May 11, 2023