Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin/master'

ToR-proposed.adoc

@@ -0,0 +1,80 @@
+= ISO/TC 211 N XXXX
+
+== Replaces N 3577
+
+=== 2024-06-26
+
+Number of pages: 3
+
+= ISO/TC 211 Geographic information/Geomatics Secretariat: SN (Norway)
+
+|===
+| *Document type:* | Other committee document
+| *Title:* | *Terms of reference, Group for ontology maintenance (GOM)*
+| *Source:* | ISO/TC 211/GOM conveors
+| *Expected action:* | Info
+| *Email to secretary:* | #?????@????#
+| *Committee URL:* | http://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/open/tc211 & https://www.isotc211.org
+|===
+
+<<<
+
+== Group for Ontology Maintenance Terms of reference
+
+=== 1. Introduction
+
+ISO/TC 211 is responsible for the standardization in the field of geographic information and, as such, has developed and maintained conceptual models for geographic information concepts in UML. In order to benefit from the Semantic Web and the Linked Open Data, ontologies in OWL are now required for these conceptual models.
+
+=== 2. Scope
+
+This document defines the terms of reference of the permanent group for the maintenance of ISO/TC 211 ontologies, called hereafter the _Group for Ontology Mantenance_ or _GOM_.
+
+=== 3. Purpose
+
+The purpose of the Group for Ontology Management is to ensure the development, maintenance and accessibility on the Web of ISO/TC 211 Semantic Web artifacts.
+
+=== 4. Responsibilities
+
+==== 4.1 Set a well-defined system of dereferenceable HTTP URIs for ISO/TC 211 concepts and their representations.
+
+==== 4.2 Set practices about the development of OWL versions of ISO/TC 211 standards' data models.
+
+==== 4.3 Ensure the development, maintenance and accessibility on the Web of OWL representations of geographic information concepts. This will address several components:
+
+- the ISO/TC 211 Multi-Lingual Glossary of Terms, and
+- vocabulary forms of ISO/TC 211 standards' codelists
+- harmonized ontology forms of ISO/TC 211 standards' data models (a reimplementation of ISO/TC 211 Harmonized Mode in Semantic Web form).
+
+==== 5. Membership
+
+The convenor of GOM is appointed by ISO/TC 211.
+
+Ex officio members:
+
+- ISO/TC 211 Chair
+- ISO/TC 211 Working Group convenors (e.g., PMG, HMMG, TMG, XMG)
+- ISO/TC 211 Spetial Group convenors (e.g., ISO/TC 211 – OGC JAG, ISO/TC211 – ISO/TC 204)
+- ISO/TC 211 project leaders 
+
+Nominated members:
+
+- Each P-member can nominate one expert in the group.
+
+Observers:
+
+- The convenor of GOM may nominate or invite additional experts.
+̶  Members may nominate observers.
+
+The membership is reviewed every three years.
+
+==== 6. Process
+
+Decisions shall be made by consensus of the full membership. If a consensus cannot be reached, a decision will be made by simple majority of nominated members.
+
+==== 7. Report
+
+A summary report of GOM activities shall be presented to each ISO/TC 211 plenary.
+
+==== 8. Review of the terms of reference
+
+The terms of reference of the Group for Ontology Maintenance shall be revisited every three years. The process shall be initiated by the Group for Ontology Maintenance Convenor and shall include the nominated members.

ToR.adoc

@@ -0,0 +1,79 @@
+= ISO/TC 211 N XXXX
+
+== Replaces N 3577
+
+=== 2024-06-26
+
+Number of pages: 3
+
+= ISO/TC 211 Geographic information/Geomatics Secretariat: SN (Norway)
+
+|===
+| *Document type:* | Other committee document
+| *Title:* | *Terms of reference, Group for ontology maintenance (GOM)*
+| *Source:* | ISO/TC 211/GOM conveors
+| *Expected action:* | Info
+| *Email to secretary:* | #?????@????#
+| *Committee URL:* | http://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/open/tc211 & https://www.isotc211.org
+|===
+
+<<<
+
+== Group for Ontology Maintenance Terms of reference
+
+=== 1. Introduction
+
+ISO/TC 211 is responsible for the standardization in the field of geographic information and, as such, has developed and maintained conceptual models for geographic information concepts in UML. In order to benefit from the Semantic Web and the Linked Open Data, ontologies in OWL are now required for the ISO/TC 211 standards.
+
+=== 2. Scope
+
+This document defines the terms of reference of the permanent group for the maintenance of ISO/TC 211 ontologies, called hereafter the _Group for Ontology Mantenance_ or _GOM_.
+
+=== 3. Purpose
+
+The purpose of the Group for Ontology Management is to ensure the development, maintenance and accessibility on the Web of ISO/TC 211 ontologies.
+
+=== 4. Responsibilities
+
+==== 4.1 Set a well-defined system of dereferenceable HTTP URIs for ISO/TC 211 concepts and their representations.
+
+==== 4.2 Set practices about the use of ISO/TC 211 XML encodings (e.g. ISO 19136, ISO/TS 19139) in OWL for the description of data values of geographic information.
+
+==== 4.3 Ensure the development, maintenance and accessibility on the Web of OWL representations of geographic information concepts. This will address two components:
+
+- the ISO/TC 211 Multi-Lingual Glossary of Terms, and
+- the ISO/TC 211 harmonized concepts (based on the ISO/TC 211 Harmonized Mode).
+
+==== 5. Membership
+
+The convenor of GOM is appointed by ISO/TC 211.
+
+Ex officio members:
+
+- ISO/TC 211 Chair
+- ISO/TC 211 Working Group convenors (e.g., PMG, HMMG, TMG, XMG)
+- ISO/TC 211 Spetial Group convenors (e.g., ISO/TC 211 – OGC JAG, ISO/TC211 – ISO/TC 204)
+- ISO/TC 211 project leaders 
+
+Nominated members:
+
+- Each P-member can nominate one expert in the group.
+
+Observers:
+
+- The convenor of GOM may nominate or invite additional experts.
+̶  Members may nominate observers.
+
+The membership is reviewed every three years.
+
+==== 6. Process
+
+Decisions shall be made by consensus of the full membership. If a consensus cannot be reached, a decision will be made by simple majority of nominated members.
+
+==== 7. Report
+
+A summary report of GOM activities shall be presented to each ISO/TC 211 plenary.
+
+==== 8. Review of the terms of reference
+
+The terms of reference of the Group for Ontology Maintenance shall be revisited every three years. The process shall be initiated by the Group for Ontology Maintenance Convenor and shall include the nominated members.

meetings/plenary-2024-06-26.adoc

@@ -0,0 +1,50 @@
+= June 2024 Plenary 
+
+== Agenda
+
+This Agenda will be lead by the GOM convenors with a brief discussion on each point and showing of online resources where indicated.
+
+=== Agenda Outline
+
+. *Welcome*
+. *Reminder of the purpose of GOM*
+.. Updated Terms of Reference
+. *Update on GOM standards review process*
+. *ISO/TC211 Harmonized Resources Registry*
+. *Discussion*
+. *Next Meeting*
+
+=== Agenda Details
+
+. *Welcome*
+.. Reminder of https://www.iso.org/publication/PUB100397.html[ISO Code of Conduct]
+.. Meeting protocols
+.. Roll call
+... (re)introduction of co-chairs: Ivana & Nicholas
+.. How to contribute/amend Agenda/Minutes
+.. Start Recording
+. *Reminder of the purpose of GOM*
+.. purpose as it has been to date
+.. purpose continuing
+. *Updated Terms of Reference*
+. *Update on GOM standards review process*
+.. GOM is reviewing the standards using the standards assessment procedure introduced to the ISO/TC211 in December'22 
+.. standards reviewed since the last meeting: ISO 19109, ISO 19178-1, ISO 19177-1
+... see https://github.com/ISO-TC211/GOM/tree/master/standards-assessment/reports
+. *Progress on vocabulary publication*
+. *OGC support of ISO/TC211 resource publication*
+. *Proposed next generation ontology publication*
+. *Demonstration of OGC GeoSPARQL publication*
+. *Discussion*
+.. Which resources will ISO/TC Harmonized Maintenance Agency curate?
+... HM from https://github.com/ISO-TC211/HMMG
+... XML from https://github.com/ISO-TC211/XMG
+... OWL from https://github.com/ISO-TC211/GOM
+... codelists
+... links to registers together and where are they used:
+
+. *Next Meeting*
+.. When: Likely on 13 November 2024 in Sydney, AU
+.. Proposed Agenda:
+... Update on standards assessment - not only which, but also how
+... Demonstration of ISO GeoSPARQL publication

meetings/plenary-2024-11-13.adoc

@@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
+= November 2024 Plenary 
+
+== Agenda
+
+This Agenda will be lead by the GOM convenors with a brief discussion on each point and showing of online resources where indicated.
+
+=== Agenda Outline
+
+. *Welcome*
+. *Reminder of the purpose of GOM*
+.. Updated Terms of Reference
+. *Update on GOM standards review process*
+. *ISO/TC211 Harmonized Resources Registry*
+. *Discussion*
+. *Next Meeting*
+
+=== Agenda Details
+
+. *Welcome*
+.. Reminder of https://www.iso.org/publication/PUB100397.html[ISO Code of Conduct]
+.. Meeting protocols
+.. Roll call
+... (re)introduction of co-chairs: Ivana & Nicholas
+.. How to contribute/amend Agenda/Minutes
+.. Start Recording
+. *Reminder of the purpose of GOM*
+.. purpose as it has been to date
+.. purpose continuing
+. *Updated Terms of Reference*:
+.. CIB Resolution 2024-07
+.. GOM Revised ToR approved - see N6056
+. *Update on GOM standards review process*
+.. GOM is reviewing the standards using the standards assessment procedure introduced to the ISO/TC211 in December'22 
+.. standards reviewed since the last meeting: none since Jun'24 plenary
+... see https://github.com/ISO-TC211/GOM/tree/master/standards-assessment/reports
+. *Progress on vocabulary publication*
+. *Discussion*
+
+
+. *Next Meeting*
+.. When: 
+.. Proposed Agenda:
+... TBD

standards-assessment/reports/19109.adoc

@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
+= GOM Standard Assessment Report
+
+== 19109 Geographic Information – General Feature Model and rules for application schemas
+
+== Document Metadata Assessment
+
+[cols="1,8"]
+|===
+| Element | Value
+
+| IRI | allocated: `https://standards.isotc211.org/19109/-/` for the Standard's document, suggested `https://def.isotc211.org/iso19109/-/` for the model and `https://def.isotc211.org/iso19109/-/1` for v1 of the model
+| Title | 19109 Geographic Information – General Feature Model and rules for application schemas
+| Edition | 1
+| Reviewer(s) | Nicholas Car & Ivana Ivánová
+|===
+
+_incomplete_... perhaps the metadata required for ConceptSchemes should be required for the Standard
+
+== Section Assessment
+
+=== Determine Document Sections
+
+The sections in this standard relevant for semantic assessment are determined to be:
+
+* *2 Normative references*
+** contains a structured bibligraphy, members of which may be referred to by multiple standards
+* *3 Terms and definitions*
+** these form a vocabulary and vocabulary elements may be used in multiple standards
+* *4 Conformance*
+** the list of Conformance Classes here form vocabularies
+* *7 General Feature Model*
+** the list of Conformance classes, Requirements Recommendations & Permissions given here form vocabularies
+* *8 Rules for Application Schema*
+** the list of Conformance classes, Requirements Recommendations & Permissions given here form vocabularies
+* *Annex A - Abstract test suites*
+** contains a vocabulary of Conformance Tests
+* *Bibliography*
+** contains a structured bibligraphy, members of which may be referred to by multiple Standards
+
+=== Recommendations per section
+
+|===
+| Section | Recommendation | Next action for this Standard
+
+| *2 Normative references* 
+| A Semantic Web form of an ISO TC 211 bibliographic references library should be created and authoratitive references to elements within it used instead of textual references
+| None: pending a TC 211 references library
+| *3 Terms and definitions* | Placement within GeoLexica | Ensure item noted in TMG Review
+| *4 Conformance* | Establish SW vocabularies for these elements | Talk with GOM regarding this new form of vocabulary
+| *7 General Feature Model* | Establish SW vocabularies for these elements | Talk with GOM regarding this new form of vocabulary
+| *9 Rules for Application Schema* | Establish SW vocabularies for these elements | Talk with GOM regarding this new form of vocabulary
+| *Annex A - Abstract test suites* | Establish SW vocabularies for these elements | Talk with GOM regarding this new form of vocabulary
+| *Bibliography* | As per *2 Normative references* | -
+|===

standards-assessment/reports/19124-1.adoc

@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ The sections in this technical specification relevant for semantic assessment ar
 ** contains one enumeration for "domain codes"
 ** _see demonstration delivery of these codelists at http://115.146.86.155/vocab/EvaluationMethodTypeCode & http://115.146.86.155/vocab/ValueStructure_
 * *Bibliography*
-** contains a structured bibligraphy, members of which may be referred to by multiple Standards
+** contains a structured bibliography, members of which may be referred to by multiple Standards
 
 === Recommendations per section