Determine a Prototype from a number of runs of Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) measuring its similarities with S-CLOP: A procedure to select the LDA run with highest mean pairwise similarity, which is measured by S-CLOP (Similarity of multiple sets by Clustering with Local Pruning), to all other runs. LDA runs are specified by its assignments leading to estimators for distribution parameters. Repeated runs lead to different results, which we encounter by choosing the most representative LDA run as prototype.
Please cite the JOSS paper using the BibTeX entry
@article{<placeholder>,
title = {{ldaPrototype}: A method in {R} to get a Prototype of multiple Latent Dirichlet Allocations},
author = {Jonas Rieger},
journal = {Journal of Open Source Software},
year = {2020},
volume = {5},
number = {51},
pages = {2181},
doi = {10.21105/joss.02181},
url = {https://doi.org/10.21105/joss.02181}
}
which is also obtained by the call citation("ldaPrototype").
- Rieger, J., Jentsch, C. & Rahnenführer, J.: LDAPrototype: A Model Selection Algorithm to Improve Reliability of Latent Dirichlet Allocation. preprint
- Rieger, J. (2020). ldaPrototype: A method in R to get a Prototype of multiple Latent Dirichlet Allocations. Journal of Open Source Software, 5(51), 2181.
- Rieger, J., Rahnenführer, J. & Jentsch, C. (2020). Improving Latent Dirichlet Allocation: On Reliability of the Novel Method LDAPrototype. Natural Language Processing and Information Systems, NLDB 2020. LNCS 12089, pp. 118-125.
Please also have a look at this short overview on topic modeling in R:
- Wiedemann, G. (2022). The World of Topic Modeling in R. M&K Medien & Kommunikationswissenschaft, 70(3), pp. 286-291.
- tm is useful for preprocessing text data.
- lda offers a fast implementation of the Latent Dirichlet Allocation and is used by
ldaPrototype. - quanteda is a framework for "Quantitative Analysis of Textual Data".
- stm is a framework for Structural Topic Models.
- tosca is a framework for statistical methods in content analysis including visualizations and validation techniques. It is also useful for managing and manipulating text data to a structure requested by
ldaPrototype. - topicmodels is another framework for various topic models based on the Latent Dirichlet Allocation and Correlated Topics Models.
- ldatuning is a framework for finding the optimal number of topics using various metrics.
This R package is licensed under the GPLv3. For bug reports (lack of documentation, misleading or wrong documentation, unexpected behaviour, ...) and feature requests please use the issue tracker. Pull requests are welcome and will be included at the discretion of the author.
install.packages("ldaPrototype")
For the development version use devtools:
devtools::install_github("JonasRieger/ldaPrototype")
Load the package and the example dataset from Reuters consisting of 91 articles - tosca::LDAprep can be used to manipulate text data to the format requested by ldaPrototype.
library("ldaPrototype")
data(reuters_docs)
data(reuters_vocab)
Run the shortcut function to create a LDAPrototype object. It consists of the LDAPrototype of 4 LDA runs (with specified seeds) with 10 topics each. The LDA selected by the algorithm can be retrieved using getPrototype or getLDA.
res = LDAPrototype(docs = reuters_docs, vocabLDA = reuters_vocab, n = 4, K = 10, seeds = 1:4)
proto = getPrototype(res) #= getLDA(res)
The same result can also be achieved by executing the following lines of code in several steps, which can be useful for interim evaluations.
reps = LDARep(docs = reuters_docs, vocab = reuters_vocab,
n = 4, K = 10, seeds = 1:4)
topics = mergeTopics(reps, vocab = reuters_vocab)
jacc = jaccardTopics(topics)
sclop = SCLOP.pairwise(jacc)
res2 = getPrototype(reps, sclop = sclop)
proto2 = getPrototype(res2) #= getLDA(res2)
identical(res, res2)
There is also the option to use similarity measures other than the Jaccard coefficient. Currently, the measures cosine similarity (cosineTopics), Jensen-Shannon divergence (jsTopics) and rank-biased overlap (rboTopics) are implemented in addition to the standard Jaccard coefficient (jaccardTopics).
To get an overview of the workflow, the associated functions and getters for each type of object, the following call is helpful:
?`ldaPrototype-package`
Similar to the quick start example, the shortcut of one single call is again compared with the step-by-step procedure.
We model 5 LDAs with K = 12 topics, hyperparameters alpha = eta = 0.1 and seeds 1:5. We want to calculate the log likelihoods for the 20 iterations after 5 burn-in iterations and topic similarities should be based on atLeast = 3 words (see Step 3 below). In addition, we want to keep all interim calculations, which would be discarded by default to save memory space.
res = LDAPrototype(docs = reuters_docs, vocabLDA = reuters_vocab,
n = 5, K = 12, alpha = 0.1, eta = 0.1, compute.log.likelihood = TRUE,
burnin = 5, num.iterations = 20, atLeast = 3, seeds = 1:5,
keepLDAs = TRUE, keepSims = TRUE, keepTopics = TRUE)
Based on res we can have a look at several getter functions:
getID(res)
getPrototypeID(res)
getParam(res)
getParam(getLDA(res))
getLDA(res, all = TRUE)
getLDA(res)
est = getEstimators(getLDA(res))
est$phi[,1:3]
est$theta[,1:3]
getLog.likelihoods(getLDA(res))
getSCLOP(res)
getSimilarity(res)[1:5, 1:5]
tosca::topWords(getTopics(getLDA(res)), 5)
In the first step we simply run the LDA procedure five times with the given parameters. This can also be done with support of batchtools using LDABatch instead of LDARep or parallelMap setting the pm.backend and (optionally) ncpus argument(s).
reps = LDARep(docs = reuters_docs, vocab = reuters_vocab,
n = 5, K = 12, alpha = 0.1, eta = 0.1, compute.log.likelihood = TRUE,
burnin = 5, num.iterations = 20, seeds = 1:5)
The topic matrices of all replications are merged and reduced to the vocabulary given in vocab. By default the vocabulary of the first topic matrix is used as a simplification of the case that all LDAs contain the same vocabulary set.
topics = mergeTopics(reps, vocab = reuters_vocab)
We use the merged topic matrix to calculate pairwise topic similarites using the Jaccard coefficient with parameters adjusting the consideration of words. A word is taken as relevant for a topic if its count passes thresholds given by limit.rel and limit.abs. A word is considered for calculation of similarities if it's relevant for the topic or if it belongs to the (atLeast =) 3 most common words in the corresponding topic. Alternatively, the similarities can also be calculated considering the cosine similarity (cosineTopics), Jensen-Shannon divergence (jsTopics - parameter epsilon to ensure computability) or rank-biased overlap (rboTopics - parameter k for maximum depth of evaluation and p as weighting parameter).
jacc = jaccardTopics(topics, limit.rel = 1/500, limit.abs = 10, atLeast = 3)
getSimilarity(jacc)[1:3, 1:3]
We can check the number of relevant and considered words using the ad-hoc getter. The difference between n1 and n2 can become larger than (atLeast =) 3 if there are ties in the count of words, which is negligible for large sample sizes.
n1 = getRelevantWords(jacc)
n2 = getConsideredWords(jacc)
(n2-n1)[n2-n1 != 0]
It is possible to represent the calulcated pairwise topic similarities as dendrogram using dendTopics and related plot options.
dend = dendTopics(jacc)
plot(dend)
The S-CLOP algorithm results in a pruning state of the dendrogram, which can be retrieved calling pruneSCLOP. By default each of the topics is colorized by its LDA run belonging; but the cluster belongings can also be visualized by the colors or by vertical lines with freely chosen parameters.
pruned = pruneSCLOP(dend)
plot(dend, pruned)
plot(dend, pruning = pruned, pruning.par = list(type = "both", lty = 1, lwd = 2, col = "red"))
For determination of the LDAPrototype the pairwise S-CLOP similarities of the 5 LDA runs are needed.
sclop = SCLOP.pairwise(jacc)
In the last step the LDAPrototype itself is determined by maximizing the mean pairwise S-CLOP per LDA.
res2 = getPrototype(reps, sclop = sclop)
There are several possibilites for using shortcut functions to summarize steps of the procedure. For example, we can determine the LDAPrototype after Step 1:
res3 = getPrototype(reps, atLeast = 3)