Add match setting in sub collection #116
Conversation
WalkthroughThis pull request introduces a new class, Changes
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 4
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (9)
data/lib/utils/constant/firestore_constant.dart (1)
4-5: LGTM! Consider adding a comment for clarity.The new constants
matchSettingSubCollectionandsettingDocumentare well-placed and follow the existing naming conventions. They appear to represent new Firestore subcollections or documents related to match settings.For improved clarity, consider adding a brief comment above these new constants to explain their purpose, similar to the existing "collection" comment. For example:
// collection static const String matchesCollection = "matches"; + // match setting subcollection and document static const String matchSettingSubCollection = "match_setting"; static const String settingDocument = "setting";data/lib/api/match/match_model.dart (1)
67-70: Consider using camelCase for property names.While the current naming convention (snake_case) might be consistent with the project's conventions, it's worth noting that Dart typically uses camelCase for variable and property names. If this project doesn't have a specific reason for using snake_case, consider refactoring these property names to camelCase for better alignment with Dart conventions:
@Default(true) bool continueWithInjuredPlayer, @Default(true) bool showWagonWheelForLessRun, @Default(true) bool showWagonWheelForDotBall,This suggestion is purely for maintaining consistency with Dart conventions and can be disregarded if the project has established different naming guidelines.
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/components/select_player_sheet.dart (1)
275-276: LGTM with a minor suggestion for improvement.The refactoring to use
onToggleMatchOptionChangeinstead ofonContinueWithInjuredPlayersChangeis a good improvement in the design, allowing for more uniform handling of match options.The added logic to clear injured batsmen when disabling the option is a good safety measure. However, for completeness, consider applying the same logic to
batsMan2as well.Here's a suggested improvement:
if (!isEnabled) { if (batsMan1?.performance .firstWhereOrNull( (element) => element.inning_id == state.currentInning?.id) ?.status == PlayerStatus.injured) { batsMan1 = null; } + if (batsMan2?.performance + .firstWhereOrNull( + (element) => element.inning_id == state.currentInning?.id) + ?.status == + PlayerStatus.injured) { + batsMan2 = null; + } }This ensures that both
batsMan1andbatsMan2are cleared if they are injured when the option is disabled.Also applies to: 277-289
data/lib/service/match/match_service.dart (3)
40-49: LGTM! Consider adding a brief documentation comment.The
_matchSettingDocumentmethod is well-implemented, following Firestore best practices and using a converter for type safety. As a minor suggestion, consider adding a brief documentation comment explaining the purpose and return type of this method for better maintainability.
101-106: LGTM! Consider adding error logging.The
streamMatchSettingmethod is well-implemented, providing real-time updates and including error handling. To further improve error management, consider adding error logging before throwing theAppError. This can help with debugging and monitoring in production.Example:
.handleError((error, stack) { // Log the error print('Error in streamMatchSetting: $error'); throw AppError.fromError(error, stack); });
108-112: LGTM! Consider adding input validation.The
updateMatchSettingmethod is well-implemented, usingSetOptions(merge: true)for partial updates and including error handling. To further improve robustness, consider adding input validation for thematchIdandsettingsparameters before performing the update.Example:
Future<void> updateMatchSetting(String matchId, MatchSetting settings) async { if (matchId.isEmpty) { throw ArgumentError('matchId cannot be empty'); } // Add any necessary validation for settings await _matchSettingDocument(matchId) .set(settings, SetOptions(merge: true)) .catchError((error, stack) => throw AppError.fromError(error, stack)); }khelo/assets/locales/app_en.arb (1)
686-687: LGTM! Consider updating related documentation.The changes to show a wheel for 1s, 2s, 3s, and dot balls appear to be a good UI improvement. This should make the scoring process more intuitive and visually engaging for users.
Don't forget to update any related documentation or user guides to reflect this new UI feature. This will ensure users are aware of the new wheel interface for these scoring events.
data/lib/api/match/match_model.freezed.dart (1)
987-1178: Good implementation, but consider Dart naming conventions and default values.The
MatchSettingclass is well-structured and correctly implements the Freezed package for immutability and JSON serialization. However, there are a couple of points to consider:
The property names use snake_case, which is not typical for Dart. Consider renaming them to camelCase for better consistency with Dart conventions:
continue_with_injured_player->continueWithInjuredPlayershow_wagon_wheel_for_less_run->showWagonWheelForLessRunshow_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball->showWagonWheelForDotBallAll boolean properties have a default value of
true. Consider if this is the desired default behavior for all settings, or if some should default tofalse.Here's a suggested refactor for the class definition:
@freezed class MatchSetting with _$MatchSetting { const factory MatchSetting({ @Default(false) bool continueWithInjuredPlayer, @Default(true) bool showWagonWheelForLessRun, @Default(false) bool showWagonWheelForDotBall, }) = _MatchSetting; factory MatchSetting.fromJson(Map<String, dynamic> json) => _$MatchSettingFromJson(json); }This refactor assumes some logical defaults, but please adjust based on your specific requirements.
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (1)
Line range hint
1542-1546: Ensure_matchSettingSubscriptionis properly canceled to avoid memory leaksThe
_matchSettingSubscriptionis not canceled in the_cancelStreamSubscriptionmethod or during the disposal of the notifier. This could lead to potential memory leaks or unintended behavior.Apply this diff to cancel the subscription:
_cancelStreamSubscription() async { await _matchStreamSubscription?.cancel(); await _ballScoreStreamSubscription?.cancel(); + await _matchSettingSubscription?.cancel(); await _matchStreamController.close(); }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (11)
- data/lib/api/match/match_model.dart (2 hunks)
- data/lib/api/match/match_model.freezed.dart (1 hunks)
- data/lib/api/match/match_model.g.dart (1 hunks)
- data/lib/service/match/match_service.dart (2 hunks)
- data/lib/utils/constant/firestore_constant.dart (1 hunks)
- khelo/assets/locales/app_en.arb (1 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/components/select_fielding_position_sheet.dart (1 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/components/select_player_sheet.dart (1 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_screen.dart (6 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (10 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.freezed.dart (17 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (14)
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/components/select_fielding_position_sheet.dart (3)
94-94: LGTM: Improved clarity in toggle button titleThe change from "not show for less run" to "show wheel for less run" (as indicated by the new localization key) improves clarity by using positive phrasing. The use of a localized string is also good for internationalization.
100-100: LGTM: Improved clarity in toggle button titleThe change from "not show for dot ball" to "show wheel for dot ball" (as indicated by the new localization key) improves clarity by using positive phrasing. The use of a localized string is also good for internationalization.
94-100: Verify localization changes and consider user impactThe changes to both toggle button titles improve clarity and align with the PR objectives. They contribute to a better user experience by making the options more understandable.
Please ensure that the corresponding changes have been made in the localization files. Run the following script to check for the new localization keys:
Also, consider if these changes might affect user behavior or require updates to user documentation.
data/lib/api/match/match_model.dart (2)
65-81: LGTM: Well-structuredMatchSettingclass implementation.The new
MatchSettingclass is well-implemented with the following positive aspects:
- Consistent use of
@freezedannotation with other classes in the file.- Clear boolean properties with default values for match configuration.
- Proper implementation of factory methods for JSON and Firestore serialization.
Good job on maintaining consistency with the existing codebase structure!
65-81: Verify the usage ofMatchSettingclass in the codebase.The newly added
MatchSettingclass is not referenced or used within this file. To ensure its proper integration and usage:
- Verify that this class is being used in other parts of the codebase where match settings are relevant.
- Ensure that any existing match creation or update logic is updated to include these new settings.
- Check if the UI for creating or editing matches has been updated to allow users to configure these settings.
To help verify the integration, you can run the following script:
This script will help identify where the
MatchSettingclass is currently used and where it potentially should be integrated.✅ Verification successful
Usage of
MatchSettingclass verified across the codebase.The
MatchSettingclass is appropriately integrated and utilized in relevant parts of the codebase, including:
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dartdata/lib/service/match/match_service.dart- Generated files such as
match_model.g.dartandmatch_model.freezed.dart🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for usage of MatchSetting class in the codebase # Search for MatchSetting usage echo "Searching for MatchSetting usage:" rg "MatchSetting" --type dart # Search for potential places where MatchSetting should be used echo "\nSearching for potential integration points:" rg "createMatch|updateMatch|editMatch" --type dart # Search for UI components that might need updating echo "\nSearching for related UI components:" rg "MatchForm|MatchSettings" --type dartLength of output: 9615
data/lib/api/match/match_model.g.dart (1)
151-166: LGTM! Correct implementation of JSON serialization for MatchSettingImpl.The newly added methods
_$$MatchSettingImplFromJsonand_$$MatchSettingImplToJsonare correctly implemented for theMatchSettingImplclass. They follow the established patterns in the file:
- The
FromJsonmethod correctly handles default values for all three boolean properties.- The
ToJsonmethod properly maps all properties to their corresponding JSON keys.- The naming convention and structure are consistent with other generated code in the file.
This implementation ensures proper serialization and deserialization of the
MatchSettingImplclass, maintaining consistency with the rest of the generated code.data/lib/service/match/match_service.dart (1)
Line range hint
40-112: Overall, excellent additions to the MatchService class.The new methods (
_matchSettingDocument,streamMatchSetting, andupdateMatchSetting) are well-implemented and integrate seamlessly with the existingMatchServiceclass. They enhance the class's capabilities by providing functionality for managing match settings, including real-time updates and Firestore integration.The consistent use of error handling and Firestore best practices across these new methods aligns well with the existing codebase. These additions will likely improve the overall functionality and maintainability of the match management system.
data/lib/api/match/match_model.freezed.dart (2)
Line range hint
1-986: Well-structured models using FreezedThe existing code in this file demonstrates a consistent and well-structured approach to defining data models using the Freezed package. The models (MatchModel, MatchTeamModel, MatchPlayer, etc.) are clearly defined with appropriate properties and serialization methods.
The use of Freezed for generating immutable classes, copyWith methods, and JSON serialization is a good practice that enhances code reliability and reduces boilerplate.
Also applies to: 1179-1947
Line range hint
1-1947: Overall good structure with minor improvements needed for the new classThis file demonstrates a well-organized approach to defining data models using the Freezed package. The addition of the
MatchSettingclass maintains consistency with the existing structure. However, minor adjustments to the new class, such as adopting Dart naming conventions and reconsidering default values, would further improve the overall quality of the code.The existing models are well-defined and utilize Freezed effectively for immutability and serialization. This approach reduces boilerplate and enhances code reliability.
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_screen.dart (2)
118-123: Code is well-structured and improves clarityUsing
_getDefaultValue(state, option)enhances readability and centralizes the logic for determining default values for match options. This is a good practice.
131-142: Solid implementation for determining default match option valuesThe
_getDefaultValuemethod effectively handles the default values for differentMatchOptioncases. This improves code maintainability by centralizing the logic.khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.freezed.dart (1)
63-63: 'matchSetting' property added and correctly integrated into state managementThe
matchSettingproperty of typeMatchSettinghas been added toScoreBoardViewState. It is properly integrated throughout the state management, including thecopyWithmethods, equality checks (operator ==),hashCode, andtoStringmethods. This ensures that any state updates will accurately reflect changes to thematchSettingproperty.Also applies to: 123-138, 192-346, 451-460, 508-735, 812-1139
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (2)
55-64: Initialization of_loadMatchSetting()method is appropriateThe
_loadMatchSetting()method correctly checks for a nullmatchId, cancels any existing subscription, and sets up a new subscription tostreamMatchSetting. Error handling withdebugPrintprovides useful logging without interrupting the app flow.
1502-1514: Asynchronous operation inonFieldingPositionSelectedis correctly handledThe
onFieldingPositionSelectedmethod appropriately awaits the asynchronous_updateMatchSettingcall before proceeding, ensuring that the state is updated reliably. The parameters forshowForLessRunandshowForDotBallare correctly used to update the match settings.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (9)
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_screen.dart (4)
131-142: Well-structured_getDefaultValuemethodThe new
_getDefaultValuemethod effectively centralizes the logic for retrieving default values based onMatchOption. This improves code organization and makes it easier to manage default values.Consider adding a
// TODO:comment in thedefaultcase to remind developers to update this method when newMatchOptions are added in the future. This can help prevent potential bugs from forgetting to handle new options.switch (option) { case MatchOption.continueWithInjuredPlayer: return state.matchSetting.continue_with_injured_player; case MatchOption.showForLessRuns: return state.matchSetting.show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run; case MatchOption.showForDotBall: return state.matchSetting.show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball; default: + // TODO: Update this method when new MatchOptions are added return false; }
341-344: Consistent use ofmatchSettingin_observeShowSelectFieldingPositionSheetThe refactoring to use the
matchSettingproperty improves consistency with the rest of the codebase. This change enhances maintainability by centralizing the access to match settings.Note: There's a minor inconsistency in naming between
showForLessRunhere andshowForLessRunsin the_getDefaultValuemethod. Consider standardizing this naming across the codebase for better clarity.Also applies to: 351-354
365-367: Consistent use ofmatchSettingacross multiple methodsThe refactoring to use the
matchSettingproperty in these methods improves consistency and aligns with the rest of the codebase. This change enhances maintainability by centralizing the access to match settings.Consider refactoring the repeated code for accessing
continue_with_injured_playerinto a separate method or computed property to reduce duplication. For example:bool get continueWithInjuredPlayers => ref.read( scoreBoardStateProvider.select( (value) => value.matchSetting.continue_with_injured_player));Then you can use this getter in all the methods, simplifying the code and making it easier to maintain.
Also applies to: 382-384, 401-403, 418-420
Line range hint
1-724: Overall improvement in state management and code structureThe changes in this file significantly improve the handling of match options and state management. The introduction of the
_getDefaultValuemethod and the consistent use of thematchSettingproperty across various methods enhance code readability and maintainability.These refactorings align well with Flutter best practices for state management and make the codebase more robust and easier to update in the future.
Consider further refactoring to reduce code duplication, particularly in accessing common settings like
continue_with_injured_player. This could involve creating getter methods or computed properties for frequently accessed settings.Overall, these changes represent a positive step towards a more maintainable and consistent codebase.
data/lib/api/user/user_models.freezed.dart (1)
Line range hint
1-852: Overall improvements in JSON handling for data models.The changes made to both
UserModelandApiSessionclasses consistently enhance JSON serialization capabilities and provide better control over which properties are included in JSON operations. These modifications will likely improve data handling, especially in API communications and data persistence scenarios.However, it's important to note that this is a generated file. Any changes should be made to the source file that generates this code, not directly to this file.
Ensure that the source file generating this code (likely named
user_models.dartor similar) has been properly updated with the necessary annotations or configurations to produce these changes. This will maintain consistency and prevent loss of changes during code regeneration.khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (4)
55-64: LGTM: Well-implemented match setting loading methodThe
_loadMatchSettingmethod is well-structured and includes proper null checks, state updates, and error handling. It effectively sets up a subscription to stream match settings and updates the state accordingly.A minor suggestion for improvement:
Consider using a logging library instead ofdebugPrintfor more robust error logging in production environments.
1227-1243: LGTM: Well-implemented match option toggle methodThe
onToggleMatchOptionChangemethod is well-structured and correctly handles different match options. It appropriately updates theMatchSettingbased on the provided option and boolean value.A suggestion for improvement:
Consider using an early return for the default case to make the flow more explicit:switch (option) { case MatchOption.continueWithInjuredPlayer: setting = setting.copyWith(continue_with_injured_player: isTrue); break; case MatchOption.showForLessRuns: setting = setting.copyWith(show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run: isTrue); break; case MatchOption.showForDotBall: setting = setting.copyWith(show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball: isTrue); break; default: - return; + return; // Early return for unhandled cases } + _updateMatchSetting(setting); - _updateMatchSetting(setting);This change makes it clearer that the method returns early for unhandled cases and only calls
_updateMatchSettingwhen a valid option is processed.
1245-1256: LGTM: Well-implemented match setting update methodThe
_updateMatchSettingmethod is well-structured with proper null checks and error handling. It correctly updates both the database and local state to ensure consistency.A suggestion for improvement:
Consider adding a loading state while the update is in progress:Future<void> _updateMatchSetting(MatchSetting setting) async { final matchId = this.matchId ?? state.match?.id; if (matchId == null) return; - state = state.copyWith(actionError: null); + state = state.copyWith(actionError: null, isActionInProgress: true); try { await _matchService.updateMatchSetting(matchId, setting); - state = state.copyWith(matchSetting: setting); + state = state.copyWith(matchSetting: setting, isActionInProgress: false); } catch (e) { - state = state.copyWith(actionError: e); + state = state.copyWith(actionError: e, isActionInProgress: false); debugPrint( "ScoreBoardViewNotifier: Error while update match setting -> $e"); } }This change will provide better feedback to the user during the update process.
1505-1517: LGTM: Updated fielding position selection with match setting updateThe changes in the
onFieldingPositionSelectedmethod correctly incorporate updating the match settings before handling the ball addition. This ensures that the latest settings are applied when processing the fielding position selection.A suggestion for improvement:
Consider handling potential errors from_updateMatchSetting:Future<void> onFieldingPositionSelected( ScoreButton tapped, bool isLongTapped, FieldingPositionType position, bool showForLessRun, bool showForDotBall, ) async { final setting = state.matchSetting.copyWith( show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run: showForLessRun, show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball: showForDotBall, ); - await _updateMatchSetting(setting); + try { + await _updateMatchSetting(setting); + } catch (e) { + // Handle error (e.g., show an error message to the user) + debugPrint("Error updating match setting: $e"); + return; // Consider whether to proceed with ball handling if setting update fails + } state = state.copyWith(position: position); _handleAddingBall(tapped, isLongTapped); }This change ensures that any errors during the match setting update are properly handled and logged.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (8)
- data/lib/api/ball_score/ball_score_model.freezed.dart (72 hunks)
- data/lib/api/innings/inning_model.freezed.dart (5 hunks)
- data/lib/api/match/match_model.freezed.dart (41 hunks)
- data/lib/api/support/support_models.freezed.dart (11 hunks)
- data/lib/api/team/team_model.freezed.dart (12 hunks)
- data/lib/api/user/user_models.freezed.dart (12 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_screen.dart (6 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (10 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (47)
data/lib/api/innings/inning_model.freezed.dart (6)
32-34: LGTM: Addition oftoJson()methodThe addition of the
toJson()method with its documentation comment is a good practice for JSON serialization. This change enhances the model's functionality by providing a clear way to convert theInningModelto a JSON map.
35-37: LGTM: Improved documentation and JSON key annotation forcopyWithThe added documentation for the
copyWithmethod enhances code readability by clearly explaining its purpose. The updated@JsonKeyannotation is more explicit about excluding this method from JSON serialization and deserialization, which is appropriate for a utility method likecopyWith.
69-70: LGTM: Added documentation forcallmethodThe addition of documentation comments to the
callmethod in the_$InningModelCopyWithImplclass improves code readability. This change is consistent with the documentation added to thecopyWithmethod in the mixin, maintaining a uniform approach to code documentation.
259-259: LGTM: Updated JSON key annotation forhashCodeThe
@JsonKeyannotation for thehashCodegetter has been updated to be more explicit about excluding it from JSON serialization and deserialization. This change is consistent with the annotation update for thecopyWithmethod and provides clearer intent in the generated code.
311-314: LGTM: Improved documentation and JSON key annotation for abstractcopyWithThe changes to the
copyWithgetter in the_InningModelabstract class are consistent with earlier updates:
- The added documentation enhances code readability by clearly explaining the getter's purpose.
- The updated
@JsonKeyannotation explicitly excludes this getter from JSON serialization and deserialization.These changes maintain consistency throughout the generated code and improve overall code quality.
Line range hint
1-314: Overall assessment: Improved code quality and consistencyThe changes made to this generated file consistently enhance code quality through:
- Addition of the
toJson()method for JSON serialization.- Improved documentation for
copyWithmethods and getters.- More explicit
@JsonKeyannotations for better control over JSON serialization.These modifications improve code readability, maintainability, and provide clearer intent in the generated code. The changes are consistent throughout the file and align with best practices for Dart and JSON serialization.
data/lib/api/support/support_models.freezed.dart (5)
33-35: LGTM: Addition of toJson methodThe addition of the
toJsonmethod to theAddSupportCaseRequestclass is a good practice. It allows for easy serialization of the object to JSON format, which is often necessary for API communication or data storage.
38-38: Improved JSON serialization controlThe update from
@JsonKey(ignore: true)to@JsonKey(includeFromJson: false, includeToJson: false)for thecopyWithmethods is a good change. It provides more explicit control over JSON serialization and deserialization, ensuring that these methods are correctly excluded from both processes.Also applies to: 252-252, 314-314, 328-328, 483-483, 509-509
36-37: Improved code documentationThe addition of documentation comments for the
copyWithmethods in bothAddSupportCaseRequestandAttachmentclasses is a great improvement. These comments clearly explain the purpose of the method, enhancing code readability and maintainability.Also applies to: 70-71, 144-145, 264-265, 311-312, 326-327, 356-357, 410-411, 481-482, 506-507
Line range hint
1-511: Consistent changes across classesThe changes have been consistently applied to both the
AddSupportCaseRequestandAttachmentclasses. This includes the updated@JsonKeyannotations and the addition of documentation comments for thecopyWithmethods. This consistency helps maintain a clean and predictable API structure.
Line range hint
1-511: Overall improvements to generated codeThe changes made to this generated file (
support_models.freezed.dart) are well-structured and consistent. Key improvements include:
- Addition of the
toJsonmethod toAddSupportCaseRequestfor JSON serialization.- Updated
@JsonKeyannotations for better control over JSON serialization and deserialization.- Added documentation comments for
copyWithmethods, enhancing code readability.These changes improve the overall functionality and maintainability of the code while respecting the constraints of working with generated files. Great job on making these enhancements!
data/lib/api/team/team_model.freezed.dart (6)
36-41: Improved serialization and documentation for TeamModelThe changes in this segment enhance the
TeamModelclass in several ways:
- The new
toJson()method facilitates JSON serialization, which is crucial for data persistence and API communication.- The added documentation for the
copyWithmethod improves code readability and maintainability.- The updated
@JsonKeyannotation provides finer control over JSON serialization, explicitly excluding thecopyWithmethod from both serialization and deserialization processes.These improvements align with best practices for data modeling and serialization in Dart.
74-75: Enhanced documentation for TeamModelCopyWithThe addition of documentation to the
callmethod ofTeamModelCopyWithis a positive change:
- It improves code readability and maintainability.
- It provides clear information about the purpose and behavior of the
copyWithfunctionality.- This change is consistent with the documentation added to the
TeamModelclass, maintaining a uniform approach to code documentation.This improvement contributes to better overall code quality and developer experience.
Line range hint
302-319: Refined JSON handling and documentation in TeamModel implementationThe changes in this segment further enhance the
TeamModelimplementation:
- The updated
@JsonKeyannotation forhashCodeandcopyWithensures these elements are excluded from JSON serialization and deserialization, which is appropriate as they are not part of the data model.- The added documentation for the
copyWithgetter improves code readability and maintains consistency with earlier documentation changes.These refinements contribute to a more robust and well-documented data model, which aligns with best practices in Dart development.
392-397: Consistent improvements in TeamPlayer classThe changes to the
TeamPlayerclass mirror those made toTeamModel, maintaining consistency across the codebase:
- The addition of the
toJson()method enhances serialization capabilities forTeamPlayerobjects.- The new documentation for the
copyWithmethod improves code readability and understanding.- The updated
@JsonKeyannotation provides precise control over JSON serialization, excluding thecopyWithmethod from both serialization and deserialization.These consistent improvements across related classes contribute to a more maintainable and well-structured codebase.
Line range hint
487-591: Consistent refinements in TeamPlayer implementationThe changes in the
TeamPlayerimplementation maintain consistency with theTeamModelimprovements:
- Added documentation for the
callmethod ofTeamPlayerCopyWithenhances code clarity.- Updated
@JsonKeyannotations forhashCodeandcopyWithensure proper JSON handling.- New documentation for the
copyWithgetter improves code readability.These consistent refinements across related classes contribute to a more cohesive, maintainable, and well-documented codebase. The uniformity in these changes demonstrates a systematic approach to code improvement.
Line range hint
1-591: Summary: Comprehensive improvements to TeamModel and TeamPlayerThe changes in this file represent a systematic and consistent set of improvements to both the
TeamModelandTeamPlayerclasses:
- Enhanced JSON serialization with new
toJson()methods.- Improved documentation for
copyWithmethods and getters.- Refined
@JsonKeyannotations for better control over JSON serialization.These changes collectively contribute to:
- Improved data persistence and API communication capabilities.
- Enhanced code readability and maintainability.
- More precise control over JSON handling.
The consistency of these improvements across related classes demonstrates a thoughtful approach to code refinement, resulting in a more robust and developer-friendly codebase.
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_screen.dart (1)
118-123: Improved code structure in_moreOptionButtonThe refactoring of the
defaultEnabledlogic into a separate_getDefaultValuemethod enhances code readability and maintainability. This change makes it easier to update the default values for different match options in the future.data/lib/api/user/user_models.freezed.dart (4)
40-42: Addition of toJson() method enhances serialization capabilities.The new
toJson()method allows for easy serialization ofUserModelinstances to JSON format, which is crucial for data persistence and API communication.
45-45: Modification of JSON key annotations improves control over serialization.The
@JsonKey(includeFromJson: false, includeToJson: false)annotation oncopyWith,hashCode, andcopyWithgetter methods ensures these are excluded from JSON serialization and deserialization. This is a good practice as these methods are typically not needed in JSON representations of the model.Also applies to: 399-399, 420-422, 495-495
517-519: Addition of toJson() method to ApiSession class.Similar to the UserModel, the new
toJson()method in ApiSession allows for easy serialization to JSON format, maintaining consistency across model classes.
522-522: Consistent JSON key annotations applied to ApiSession class.The
@JsonKey(includeFromJson: false, includeToJson: false)annotations have been consistently applied to thecopyWith,hashCode, andcopyWithgetter methods in the ApiSession class, mirroring the changes in UserModel. This ensures uniform behavior across model classes during JSON operations.Also applies to: 778-778, 793-795, 850-850
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (5)
38-38: LGTM: New stream subscription for MatchSettingThe addition of
_matchSettingSubscriptionis a good practice for managing the subscription to match settings. This will allow for proper handling and disposal of the subscription when needed.
52-53: LGTM: Added match setting loadingThe addition of
_loadMatchSetting()in thesetDatamethod is a good way to initialize the match settings when setting up the data. This separation of concerns improves the code organization.
543-544: LGTM: Updated fielding position sheet logicThe changes in the
_showFieldingPositionSheetmethod correctly incorporate the newmatchSettingstate to determine when to show the fielding position sheet. This update aligns well with the new match setting functionality.
1602-1602: LGTM: Added match setting to ScoreBoardViewStateThe addition of the
matchSettingfield to theScoreBoardViewStateclass with a default value is a good practice. It ensures that the state always has a validMatchSettingobject, which aligns well with the new match setting functionality.
Line range hint
1-1702: Overall assessment: Well-implemented match setting functionalityThe changes in this file successfully introduce and integrate match setting functionality into the score board view model. The new methods for loading, updating, and using match settings are well-structured and properly integrated with the existing code. The changes maintain consistency with the current coding style and follow good practices for state management and error handling.
Some minor suggestions for improvement have been made, primarily focusing on enhanced error handling and slight adjustments to code structure. These suggestions, if implemented, would further improve the robustness and clarity of the code.
Overall, the changes represent a solid enhancement to the score board functionality, allowing for more flexible and customizable match settings.
data/lib/api/match/match_model.freezed.dart (7)
60-65: LGTM: Improved serialization and immutability for MatchModelThe addition of the
toJson()method and the updatedcopyWithmethod enhance theMatchModelclass. These changes improve serialization capabilities and reinforce the immutability pattern, which are both good practices in Dart.
126-127: LGTM: Improved documentation for MatchModel copyWith methodThe added documentation for the
copyWithmethod enhances code readability and maintainability. This is a good practice that helps developers understand the purpose and usage of the method.
1004-1208: LGTM: New MatchSetting class added with proper structureThe new
MatchSettingclass is well-implemented, following Freezed package conventions for immutability and JSON serialization. This addition enhances the match model by allowing configuration of specific match settings.However, please verify if the default
truevalues for all boolean properties are intentional and align with the expected default behavior:continue_with_injured_player = true, show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run = true, show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball = trueCould you confirm if these default values are correct according to the business requirements?
1226-1231: LGTM: Enhanced MatchTeamModel with improved serialization and immutabilityThe updates to the
toJson()andcopyWithmethods in theMatchTeamModelclass align with the changes made to theMatchModelclass. These modifications improve serialization capabilities and reinforce the immutability pattern, which are good practices in Dart.
1550-1555: LGTM: Improved MatchPlayer with better serialization and immutabilityThe updates to the
toJson()andcopyWithmethods in theMatchPlayerclass are consistent with the changes made to other classes in this file. These modifications enhance serialization capabilities and reinforce the immutability pattern, maintaining good coding practices throughout the model classes.
1793-1798: LGTM: Enhanced PlayerPerformance with improved serialization and immutabilityThe updates to the
toJson()andcopyWithmethods in thePlayerPerformanceclass align with the changes made to other classes in this file. These modifications improve serialization capabilities and reinforce the immutability pattern, maintaining consistency across all model classes.
1982-1987: LGTM: Consistent improvements across all model classesThe updates to the
toJson()andcopyWithmethods in theRevisedTarget,TeamMatchStatus, andTeamStatclasses are consistent with the changes made to other classes in this file. These modifications enhance serialization capabilities and reinforce the immutability pattern across all model classes.Overall, this file update demonstrates a systematic improvement in the following areas:
- Enhanced serialization with the addition of
toJson()methods- Improved immutability through updated
copyWithmethods- Better documentation for some methods
- Introduction of the new
MatchSettingclass for additional configuration optionsThese changes contribute to more robust and maintainable code throughout the match model classes.
Also applies to: 2196-2198, 2367-2369
data/lib/api/ball_score/ball_score_model.freezed.dart (13)
93-94: Duplicate issue: Unnecessary@JsonKeyoncopyWithmethodThe
@JsonKeyannotation on thecopyWithmethod is also present here. Please remove it as previously suggested.
237-238: Duplicate issue: Unnecessary@JsonKeyoncopyWithmethodThe same issue with the
@JsonKeyannotation occurs in this section for thecopyWithmethod. Refer to the earlier comment for the resolution.
481-483: Duplicate issue: Unnecessary@JsonKeyoncopyWithmethod
563-567: Duplicate issue: Unnecessary@JsonKeyoncopyWithmethod
810-812: Avoid using@JsonKeyannotation on methods inBattingStat
1137-1139: Avoid using@JsonKeyannotation on methods inBowlingStat
1468-1470: Avoid using@JsonKeyannotation on methods inFieldingStat
1643-1645: Avoid using@JsonKeyannotation on methods inOverStatModel
1829-1831: Avoid using@JsonKeyannotation on methods inTeamRunStat
3397-3399: Avoid using@JsonKeyannotation on methods inExtraSummary
1826-1828: Ensure proper implementation oftoJson()inTeamRunStatUse the script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for `toJson()` method implementation in `_TeamRunStat`. ast-grep --lang dart --pattern $''' class _\$_TeamRunStat implements _TeamRunStat { Map<String, dynamic> toJson() { $$$ } } '''
1640-1642: Ensure proper implementation oftoJson()inOverStatModelThe
toJson()method is declared but throws_privateConstructorUsedError. Verify that the concrete class_OverStatModelimplementstoJson()correctly.Use the following script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for `toJson()` method implementation in `_OverStatModel`. ast-grep --lang dart --pattern $''' class _\$_OverStatModel implements _OverStatModel { Map<String, dynamic> toJson() { $$$ } } '''
456-456:⚠️ Potential issueDuplicate issue: Unnecessary
@JsonKeyonhashCodeThe
@JsonKeyannotation is applied to thehashCodegetter. Similar to methods,@JsonKeyshould not be used on getters likehashCode. This could cause issues during serialization.Apply this diff to remove the
@JsonKeyannotation:- @JsonKey(includeFromJson: false, includeToJson: false) @override int get hashCode => Object.hashAll([...]);Likely invalid or redundant comment.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (3)
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_screen.dart (3)
112-126: LGTM! Consider a minor naming improvement.The changes to the
_moreOptionButtonmethod improve code readability and maintainability. The use of_getDefaultValuecentralizes the logic for determining default values, and theonToggleMatchOptionChangemethod provides a more specific callback for toggle buttons.Consider renaming the
resultparameter in theonTapcallback to something more descriptive, such asisEnabledortoggleState, to better reflect its purpose:onTap: (result) => notifier - .onToggleMatchOptionChange(result, option), + .onToggleMatchOptionChange(isEnabled, option),
130-141: LGTM! Consider future-proofing the default case.The addition of the
_getDefaultValuemethod improves code organization by centralizing the logic for determining default values for match options. This enhances readability and maintainability.To improve future maintainability, consider throwing an exception in the default case instead of returning a default value. This will help catch any newly added
MatchOptionthat hasn't been handled:switch (option) { case MatchOption.continueWithInjuredPlayer: return state.matchSetting.continue_with_injured_player; case MatchOption.showForLessRuns: return state.matchSetting.show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run; case MatchOption.showForDotBall: return state.matchSetting.show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball; default: - return false; + throw UnimplementedError('Default value not defined for ${option.name}'); }This change will make it easier to identify and handle any new
MatchOptioncases that might be added in the future.
340-343: LGTM! Consider refactoring to reduce duplication.The changes in the
_observemethods to usematchSettinginstead of individual state properties improve consistency and centralize access to match settings. This is good for maintainability and readability.To further improve the code, consider refactoring the repeated access to
matchSettinginto a single method or getter. This would reduce code duplication and make future changes easier. For example:MatchSetting get _matchSetting => ref.read( scoreBoardStateProvider.select((value) => value.matchSetting) );Then, you can use this getter in your
_observemethods:final continueWithInjuredPlayers = _matchSetting.continue_with_injured_player; final showForLessRun = _matchSetting.show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run; final showForDotBall = _matchSetting.show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball;This refactoring would make the code more DRY and easier to maintain.
Also applies to: 364-366, 381-383, 400-402, 417-419
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (3)
- data/lib/service/match/match_service.dart (2 hunks)
- data/lib/utils/constant/firestore_constant.dart (1 hunks)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_screen.dart (6 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (2)
- data/lib/service/match/match_service.dart
- data/lib/utils/constant/firestore_constant.dart
🧰 Additional context used
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (5)
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (5)
55-63: LGTM: Well-implemented match setting loadingThe
_loadMatchSettingmethod is well-structured:
- It checks for a valid
matchIdbefore subscribing.- It correctly updates the state with new settings or retains current settings.
- Error handling is properly implemented.
Consider using a more specific error message in the
debugPrintstatement. For example:debugPrint("ScoreBoardViewNotifier: Error while loading match setting: $e");This will make debugging easier in the future.
1226-1242: LGTM: Well-implemented match option toggle handlingThe
onToggleMatchOptionChangemethod is well-structured:
- It correctly handles different match options using a switch statement.
- It updates the appropriate settings based on the toggled option.
- It calls
_updateMatchSettingto persist the changes.Consider using Dart's enhanced switch statements for a more concise implementation:
void onToggleMatchOptionChange(bool isTrue, MatchOption option) { final setting = switch (option) { MatchOption.continueWithInjuredPlayer => state.matchSetting.copyWith(continue_with_injured_player: isTrue), MatchOption.showForLessRuns => state.matchSetting.copyWith(show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run: isTrue), MatchOption.showForDotBall => state.matchSetting.copyWith(show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball: isTrue), _ => state.matchSetting, }; if (setting != state.matchSetting) { _updateMatchSetting(setting); } }This approach reduces repetition and makes the code more maintainable.
1244-1255: LGTM: Well-implemented match setting updateThe
_updateMatchSettingmethod is well-structured:
- It checks for a valid
matchIdbefore proceeding.- It updates both the database and the local state, ensuring consistency.
- Error handling is properly implemented.
Consider using a more descriptive error message in the
debugPrintstatement. For example:debugPrint("ScoreBoardViewNotifier: Failed to update match setting. Error: $e");This will provide more context when debugging.
1504-1516: LGTM: Updated fielding position selection with setting updatesThe
onFieldingPositionSelectedmethod has been correctly updated to:
- Update the match settings before handling the ball addition.
- Use the new
_updateMatchSettingmethod to persist the changes.This ensures that the latest settings are applied before processing the ball.
Consider making this method
asyncand usingawaitfor the_updateMatchSettingcall:Future<void> onFieldingPositionSelected( ScoreButton tapped, bool isLongTapped, FieldingPositionType position, bool showForLessRun, bool showForDotBall, ) async { final setting = state.matchSetting.copyWith( show_wagon_wheel_for_less_run: showForLessRun, show_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ball: showForDotBall, ); await _updateMatchSetting(setting); state = state.copyWith(position: position); _handleAddingBall(tapped, isLongTapped); }This will ensure that the settings are fully updated before proceeding with the ball handling.
Line range hint
1-1703: Overall assessment: Well-implemented match settings functionalityThe changes in this file successfully introduce and manage match settings throughout the
ScoreBoardViewNotifierclass. Key points:
- A new stream subscription for match settings has been added.
- Methods for loading and updating match settings have been implemented with proper error handling.
- Existing methods have been updated to consider these new settings in their logic.
- The changes are consistent and maintain the overall structure and style of the code.
These modifications enhance the functionality of the scoreboard, allowing for more flexible and customizable match management.
Consider breaking down this large file into smaller, more focused components in the future. This could improve maintainability and make it easier to test individual pieces of functionality.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
- khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (10 hunks)
🧰 Additional context used
🔇 Additional comments (4)
khelo/lib/ui/flow/score_board/score_board_view_model.dart (4)
38-38: LGTM: New stream subscription for MatchSettingThe addition of
_matchSettingSubscriptionis a good practice for managing the stream of match settings. This allows for proper handling and disposal of the subscription.
52-53: LGTM: Added match setting loadingThe addition of
_loadMatchSetting()call in thesetDatamethod ensures that match settings are loaded after the match and innings data. This is a logical sequence of operations.
805-813: LGTM: Updated all-out logic with injured player considerationThe
_isAllOutmethod has been correctly updated to consider thecontinue_with_injured_playersetting. This change ensures that the all-out condition is accurately determined based on whether injured players are allowed to continue.
542-543: LGTM: Updated fielding position sheet logicThe
_showFieldingPositionSheetmethod has been correctly updated to use the new match settings. It now considersshow_wagon_wheel_for_dot_ballandshow_wagon_wheel_for_less_runsettings to determine when to display the fielding position sheet.
Add Match setting in database
Simulator.Screen.Recording.-.iPhone.16.-.2024-10-09.at.17.07.50.mp4
Summary by CodeRabbit
Release Notes
New Features
MatchSettingclass for managing match configurations with default options.Bug Fixes
Documentation
Refactor