Refactor body parts hierarchy on 8.2.0 mediawiki #167
Conversation
| ***** Knee <nowiki>[A joint connecting the lower part of the femur with the upper part of the tibia.]</nowiki> | ||
| ***** Shin <nowiki>[Front part of the leg below the knee.]</nowiki> | ||
| ***** Thigh <nowiki>[Upper part of the leg between hip and knee.]</nowiki> | ||
| ******* Teeth <nowiki>[The hard bonelike structures in the jaws. A collection of teeth arranged in some pattern in the mouth or other part of the body.]</nowiki> |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I don't think that Teeth should go under Mouth.... Teeth is not a Mouth.
| ***** Torso-back <nowiki>[The rear surface of the human body from the shoulders to the hips, often regarded as the back]</nowiki> | ||
| ***** Abdomen <nowiki>[The part of the body between the thorax and the pelvis.]</nowiki> | ||
| ***** Pelvis <nowiki>[The bony structure at the base of the spine supporting the legs.]</nowiki> | ||
| ****** Buttocks <nowiki>[The round fleshy parts that form the lower rear area of a human trunk.]</nowiki> |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I don't think Buttocks should go under Pelvis. It should be at the same level. It is possible that we need to do:
**** Torso
**** Torso-part
***** Buttocks
Now that we are going to ontologies -- a strict is-a will be enforced.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Teeth is in the Mouth (cavity). The same way that is under the Head hierarchy?
| ***** Hand <nowiki>[The distal portion of the upper extremity. It consists of the carpus, metacarpus, and digits.]</nowiki> | ||
| ***** Wrist <nowiki>[A joint between the distal end of the radius and the proximal row of carpal bones.]</nowiki> | ||
| ****** Palm <nowiki>[The part of the inner surface of the hand that extends from the wrist to the bases of the fingers.]</nowiki> | ||
| ****** Knuckles <nowiki>[A part of a finger at a joint where the bone is near the surface, especially where the finger joins the hand.]</nowiki> |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Same thing here with adding parts. We need to discuss...
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Sorry, the Wrist should be under Hand.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This reorganization has raised an interesting issue. All of the items in this hierarchy are "Body-part". We have both Body and Body-part at the top level -- but the whole-part relationship was not followed. We should probably discuss. With the ontology addition we can add part-of relationships, but the HED hierarchy should probably do a strict is-a.
|
I think we have to modify the schema under @smakeig @monique2208 @neuromechanist @dorahermes @dungscout96 : As a reminder we already had this discussion in the transition from HED2 to HED3. HED2 had a mixed hierarchy with
One thing that we could do is to introduce an |
|
I'll close this PR and open another one based on the Pre-release Schema. |
Following the discussion in #164, these changes will add a couple of terms and lightly adjust the anatomical hierarchy.
This pull request will close #164.